We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Choosing the best substrate sets the tone for your entire aquarium. It affects how your fish behave, how your plants root, how your filter performs, and how easy weekly maintenance feels. Sand and gravel are the two most common options. Both can deliver a beautiful, healthy tank, but they excel in different situations. This guide breaks down how each substrate works, what it does to your water and filtration, which fish prefer which, and how to set it up the right way from day one. Read on to avoid costly mistakes and get a substrate that supports your goals rather than fighting them.
What Substrate Actually Does in Your Tank
Biological Filtration and Stability
Substrates provide a huge surface area for beneficial bacteria. These microbes convert toxic ammonia to nitrite, then nitrite to nitrate. Sand and gravel both host these bacteria, but grain size and compaction change how much oxygen reaches them. Well-oxygenated spaces support nitrifying bacteria that keep ammonia and nitrite at zero. Dense, compacted areas can go low oxygen and favor different microbes that process nitrates and organics. Understanding this helps you choose the right depth and maintenance approach.
Plant Anchorage and Nutrient Access
Rooted plants need a stable base and nutrients. Inert sand or gravel do not feed plants by themselves, but they anchor roots well if you use root tabs or nutrient-rich layers below. Nutrient soils exist too, but this guide focuses on sand and gravel. For beginners, either can work for plants if you plan your feeding strategy and depth properly.
Fish Behavior and Comfort
Many fish dig, sift, or rest on the bottom. Corydoras, loaches, and geophagus species thrive with soft, fine sand that protects barbels and allows natural foraging. Some cichlids and goldfish enjoy moving grains around, which influences your choice. Matching substrate to behavior reduces stress, improves color and activity, and lowers disease risk.
Water Chemistry and Clarity
Some substrates are inert and do not change water parameters. Others buffer pH or hardness. Grain size also affects how detritus settles and how clear water looks after disturbance. Fine grains can cloud if mishandled. Larger gravel can trap waste under the surface. Your maintenance habits and filter setup should match these tendencies.
Sand Basics
Common Types of Sand
Pool filter sand is washed, relatively uniform, and heavier than play sand. It resists clouding and works well in freshwater tanks. Blasting sand is similar but can be sharper depending on brand and grit. Aquarium cosmetic sands vary in color and grain size and are a safe choice for new keepers. Aragonite or crushed coral sands are used in hard water setups such as African cichlid or marine tanks because they raise pH and hardness. Choose inert sand for most community and planted tanks unless you specifically need buffering.
Why Choose Sand
Fine sand is gentle on barbels and skin, perfect for bottom dwellers like corydoras, kuhli loaches, and many dwarf cichlids. Fish that sift sand through their gills can perform natural feeding behavior. Detritus stays on the surface rather than falling deep between grains, making it easy to remove during water changes. Sand supports root mats that spread horizontally, anchoring carpeting plants well when paired with root tabs. It also creates a smooth, modern look that highlights fish color.
Challenges With Sand and How to Solve Them
Sand can compact and develop low oxygen zones. Keep it under about 5 cm deep in non-planted areas, stir gently during maintenance, and use rooted plants or Malaysian trumpet snails to mix upper layers. Fine sand can get sucked into filters and wear impellers. Keep the filter intake a bit higher, use prefilter sponges, and avoid stirring directly near the intake. Some sands cloud at first. Rinse thoroughly until water runs clear, or fill the tank slowly over a plate or plastic bag to avoid disturbance.
Gravel Basics
Common Types of Gravel
Inert aquarium gravel comes in coated colors and natural tones, usually 2 to 5 mm grain size. Pea gravel is larger and heavier, with variable color. Specialty planted gravels are porous and lighter, offering high surface area and better root penetration, though they are still mostly inert. Avoid sharp or jagged gravel for fish with delicate barbels. If you are unsure, rub a handful between your fingers. It should feel smooth, not cutting.
Why Choose Gravel
Gravel is forgiving for new aquarists. It does not compact as easily and allows deep oxygen penetration, supporting beneficial bacteria. It is easy to vacuum thoroughly with a siphon. Gravel holds slopes and terraces better than many sands, which helps with aquascaping. It pairs well with undergravel filters. Most medium grains do not get stirred into filters. For medium to large fish and community tanks without sand-sifting species, gravel is a solid, low-risk choice.
Challenges With Gravel and Fixes
Waste falls between gravel grains. If you skip vacuuming, it accumulates and decomposes. Use a gravel vacuum every week or two to pull debris from the gaps. Some colored gravels can leach dyes or chip coatings if the product quality is poor. Choose aquarium-grade brands. For delicate bottom dwellers, use smooth gravel only, or switch to sand. Large gravel can be hard for small plants to root in. In that case, pick smaller grain sizes around 2 to 3 mm or use root tabs to help anchoring.
Matching Substrate to Your Livestock
Bottom Dwellers and Diggers
Corydoras, kuhli loaches, hillstream loaches, dwarf chain loaches, and many dwarf cichlids prefer fine sand. Their barbels and bellies stay healthy, and they exhibit natural sifting. Geophagus and eartheater cichlids require sand to feed properly. For heavy diggers like certain cichlids, sand allows easy restructuring without injury. If your stock list features these species, sand is strongly recommended.
Plant-Heavy and Aquascaped Tanks
Both sand and gravel can support strong plant growth with the right supplements. If you plan dense carpets like dwarf hairgrass or Monte Carlo, fine to medium sand works well when combined with regular root tabs. For stem and rosette plants, medium gravel offers stable anchoring and good water flow to roots. Porous planted gravels provide extra surface area and root hold. Avoid very large or very sharp gravel that frustrates planting.
Goldfish, Barbs, and Larger Community Fish
Goldfish constantly forage on the bottom and like to move substrate. Fine sand is safe and reduces the risk of gravel getting stuck in the mouth. If using gravel, choose small, rounded grains that cannot be swallowed. Many barbs and rainbowfish do well with gravel in community tanks, where routine vacuuming is straightforward. Balance ease of cleaning with the behavior of your specific fish.
African Cichlids, Brackish, and Marine
Lake Malawi and Lake Tanganyika cichlids prefer hard, alkaline water. Aragonite sand or crushed coral can buffer pH and hardness. For brackish and marine tanks, aragonite sands are common and help maintain alkalinity. In these setups, avoid inert river gravel unless you want to manage parameters with other methods. Always match substrate buffering to your target water chemistry.
Choosing the Right Grain Size
Fine, Medium, and Coarse
Fine sand is under about 1 mm. It is best for sifters and delicate species but is more prone to compaction and clouding if mishandled. Medium substrates around 1 to 3 mm include small gravel and coarser sands. They balance root support, flow, and cleaning ease. Coarse gravel above 5 mm is suitable for large fish and undergravel filters but traps more debris and can be hard for small plants.
Visual and Practical Balance
Very light sands brighten a tank but show every speck of waste. Darker medium grains hide debris and make fish colors pop, yet still allow clear viewing. Choose a grain size that supports your livestock first, then refine by color and texture to achieve the look you want without creating maintenance headaches.
How Deep Should the Substrate Be
Depth Guidelines by Goal
For bare community tanks without many plants, aim for 3 to 5 cm. This is easy to clean and prevents deep anaerobic pockets. For planted tanks, 5 to 7 cm supports root systems and anchors larger stems. If using sand with heavy rooters, keep the lower layers a bit coarser or use root tabs to prevent compaction. For big diggers, you can go thicker but maintain a habit of gentle stirring and robust filtration.
Avoiding Dead Zones
Dead zones form when layers compact and trap gases. Keep depths moderate, add live plants that aerate the substrate, and perform periodic light stirring. Snails such as Malaysian trumpet snails move through the top layers and help keep the surface open. Do not plunge stirring tools too deep or disrupt roots in planted sections. Controlled, frequent maintenance beats rare deep disruptions.
Layering and Caps
When Layering Helps
Layering can combine benefits. A thin nutrient layer or soil capped with sand gives plants a strong start while keeping nutrients out of the water column. A mix of medium gravel under a sand cap reduces compaction and improves flow near roots. Keep layers simple and stable. If you move decor often or have heavy diggers, they may mix layers and release nutrients. In that case, stick to a single inert substrate with root tabs.
Root Tabs and Fertilizers
Inert sand and gravel rely on water column dosing and root tabs for plant nutrition. Insert tabs near heavy root feeders like swords and crypts every 2 to 3 months. Do not overdo it, and avoid placing tabs where fish dig constantly. Combine with liquid fertilizers for trace elements and potassium as needed. Adjust dosing based on plant growth and algae response.
Filter Choices and Substrate Interactions
Undergravel Filters
Undergravel filters work best with medium gravel that allows uniform upward flow. Fine sand will clog plates and choke flow. If you want sand, skip undergravel and use sponge, hang-on-back, or canister filtration. For gravel tanks with undergravel systems, regular vacuuming is essential to prevent detritus buildup under the plate.
Intakes and Flow With Sand
When using sand, raise the intake and cover it with a prefilter sponge. Aim current to reduce dead spots but avoid blasting the sand bed. Point returns slightly upward or across the water surface to keep grains down and oxygen levels high.
Maintenance Routines That Work
Cleaning Sand Without Clouding
During water changes, hover the siphon just above the surface to lift detritus without removing sand. Pinch the hose to reduce flow near the substrate. Swish gently across high traffic areas like feeding zones. Periodically stir small sections of the sand lightly to release trapped gases, but avoid uprooting plants. If you accidentally suck up sand, let it settle in the bucket and pour clean water back slowly, or accept minor sand loss and top up as needed.
Cleaning Gravel Thoroughly
Push the vacuum tube into the gravel and lift in a rhythmic pattern. Debris rises while gravel tumbles and falls back. Work in sections each week to avoid disturbing the whole bed at once. Consistent vacuuming prevents deep rot and keeps nitrates manageable. Adjust technique for grain size. Larger gravel may need deeper probing to reach trapped waste.
Preventing Anaerobic Pockets
Do not overcompress sand. Avoid heavy decor that seals large areas. Use plant roots and light stirring in non-planted sections. For gravel, routine vacuuming limits decomposing layers. If you notice sulfur smell or black streaks beneath the surface, increase maintenance, reduce depth, and improve flow.
Managing Algae and Diatoms
New sand beds often show diatoms during the first month. This usually fades as the tank matures. Control nutrients, maintain good flow, and use a cleanup crew such as nerite snails or otocinclus if compatible. Reduce excess feeding and keep lighting consistent. For gravel, the same rules apply. Clean surfaces gently and avoid harsh scrubbing that scatters debris into the water.
Changing Substrate Safely
If you switch from gravel to sand or the reverse, do it in stages to preserve bacteria. Replace one third of the substrate per week, or run extra biomedia in your filter for a few weeks before the swap. Test ammonia and nitrite daily after changes. Keep feeding light until the system stabilizes.
Budget and Aesthetic Choices
Cost and Availability
Pool filter sand and black blasting sand are often the cheapest options and widely available. Aquarium-branded sands cost more but are prewashed and consistent. Standard aquarium gravel is mid priced and easy to source. Porous specialty gravels cost more but can be worth it for planted layouts and long-term durability. Factor in how much you need. A standard 75 liter tank often uses 9 to 14 kg depending on depth and grain size.
Color and Fish Welfare
Dark substrates make fish colors stand out and can reduce stress in shy species. Very bright white can cause glare and spook some fish. Natural tones look balanced and hide debris. Choose a color that supports the behavior of your fish and the visual style you enjoy. Avoid painted gravels of questionable quality. Stick to aquarium safe products.
Water Parameters and Chemistry Effects
Inert vs Active Substrates
Inert sand and gravel do not change pH or hardness. They are ideal for community tanks and planted setups where you control nutrients and parameters with fertilizers and water changes. Active or buffering substrates such as aragonite raise pH and hardness and are used for African rift cichlids and marine tanks. Aquatic plant soils are another active category that lower pH and soften water, but they are outside this sand versus gravel focus.
When to Use Buffering Sands
Use aragonite or crushed coral sand if you keep fish that want high pH and hardness. This includes many African cichlids and marine species. Measure your tap water first. If it already matches your target, you may not need buffering sand. Stability is more important than chasing a number. Test weekly and adjust slowly.
Decision Guide
Quick Picks by Scenario
For corydoras, loaches, geophagus, and sand sifters, choose fine to medium sand. For community tanks with easy cleaning, choose medium gravel. For goldfish, choose fine sand or small rounded gravel that cannot be swallowed. For African cichlids and marine, choose aragonite or crushed coral sands. For planted tanks with carpets, choose fine to medium sand with root tabs, or a porous planted gravel with root tabs. For undergravel filters, choose medium gravel.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Do not use play sand without heavy rinsing as it compacts and clouds. Do not pick sharp gravel for barbels or bottom dwellers. Do not go too deep with fine sand unless you have strong plant roots and a plan for circulation. Do not ignore parameters after a substrate change. Do not mix buffering and non-buffering substrates randomly. Keep your approach intentional and consistent.
Sample Builds That Work
Soft water community with corydoras: medium grain inert sand at 4 cm depth, lots of driftwood, root tabs under swords and crypts, sponge or canister filter with prefilter sponge, gentle stirring in open sand zones every two weeks.
Beginner planted community: medium gravel at 5 cm depth, weekly gravel vacuum, root tabs under heavy feeders, liquid fertilizer at half dosing, moderate light, hang-on-back filter with biological media, hardy plants like Java fern and Anubias attached to wood and rock.
African cichlid rockscape: aragonite sand at 3 to 4 cm depth, robust rock piles, strong filtration and aeration, regular surface siphoning to remove waste, stable high pH and hardness, no soil or inert gravel mixed in.
Step-by-Step Setup Tips
Rinsing and Placement
Rinse sand or gravel in batches until water runs mostly clear. Add substrate to the tank before hardscape, shape slopes with support from rocks or wood, and place dishes under the fill stream so water does not blast the bed. Fill slowly at first, then adjust flow as the tank stabilizes.
Seeding and Cycling
Use established filter media or bottled bacteria to seed the new substrate. Keep the filter running 24 hours a day. Test ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate during the first month. Only stock fish once ammonia and nitrite remain at zero for several days. Feed lightly while colonies establish on the substrate and in the filter.
Early Weeks Routine
Expect minor dust or diatom film during the first 2 to 6 weeks. Perform small but regular water changes, wipe glass gently, and avoid deep disturbance. As the biofilm matures, clarity improves and algae stabilizes. Adjust light duration and nutrient inputs based on plant growth and test results.
Troubleshooting
Cloudy Water After Setup
If you see persistent cloudiness with sand, you likely skipped thorough rinsing or filled too fast. Pause feeding, run fine mechanical media like filter floss, and consider a water polishing filter for a few days. With gravel, clouding usually comes from disturbed debris, so increase vacuum frequency until the bed is clean.
Gas Bubbles and Black Patches
These are signs of trapped organics and low oxygen zones. Gently lift and fluff the top centimeter of substrate in sections each week. Reduce depth where possible, increase flow across the bottom, and bolster plant roots. Avoid overfeeding and remove decaying plant matter promptly.
Fish With Damaged Barbels
Switch to fine sand or smoother gravel and improve cleanliness. Check for sharp grains and remove rough decorative stones. Monitor ammonia and nitrite, as poor water quality also harms barbels and fins.
Budget Planning and Longevity
Getting Value for Money
Choose widely used, aquarium-safe materials that you can repurchase later for expansions or top-ups. Sand may need occasional replenishment as it gets siphoned out during maintenance. Gravel lasts many years if kept clean. Investing in a good gravel vacuum, prefilter sponges, and reliable test kits saves money by preventing problems.
Resale and Reuse
Substrates can be reused after thorough washing and drying if you break down a tank. Avoid reusing substrate from tanks with disease or copper treatments when moving to shrimp or invertebrates. When in doubt, start fresh to protect sensitive species.
Conclusion
Final Takeaways
Sand and gravel both work. Your stock list, planting plan, and maintenance style decide which is better for you. Choose sand for barbels, sifters, and natural foraging behavior. Choose medium gravel for simple cleaning, strong bacterial support, and stable aquascapes. Use buffering sands only when you need higher pH and hardness. Keep depths moderate, match grain size to goals, and maintain the bed consistently.
The Simple Choice
If you keep bottom dwellers or want a smooth, modern look, go with fine to medium inert sand and learn gentle surface cleaning. If you want a forgiving, easy to vacuum substrate for a mixed community, use medium rounded gravel. Support plants with root tabs, keep test kits on hand, and commit to steady weekly habits. Do this and your substrate becomes a foundation for success rather than a source of problems.