We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Choosing the right aquarium substrate is one of the most important decisions you will make for your tank. Substrate is not just decoration. It affects your water chemistry, your filter bacteria, your plants, and your fish. The good news is that you do not need to be a scientist to choose correctly. In this guide, you will learn what each substrate does, how it fits your goals, how much to buy, how to prepare it, and how to avoid common mistakes. By the end, you will be ready to set up a clean, healthy, and beautiful aquarium bottom that works for you and your fish.
What Is Aquarium Substrate and Why It Matters
Substrate is the material that sits on the bottom of the aquarium. Common examples are gravel, sand, and specialized plant soils. It matters for four main reasons. First, it provides living space for beneficial bacteria that help process fish waste. Second, it affects water chemistry because some materials raise or lower pH and hardness. Third, it supports plant roots and can hold nutrients for growth. Fourth, it creates the look and feeling of your aquascape and the comfort of your fish. A good substrate matches your fish and plant needs, your maintenance style, and your visual taste.
Start With Your Goal
Before you buy anything, decide what kind of tank you want. Your goal determines the right substrate more than anything else. Think about your fish species, whether you will grow real plants, and how much time you want to spend on maintenance.
Display-Only Community Tank
If you want a simple tank with hardy fish and maybe some easy plants, choose an inert substrate that does not change water chemistry. Inert gravel or silica sand works well. This choice is stable, easy to clean, and safe for most community fish.
Planted Aquascape
If you plan to grow many plants, consider a nutrient-rich plant soil, often called aquasoil, or a layered system that includes enriched material. Aquasoil makes plants easier for beginners because it holds nutrients and keeps roots happy. It may lower pH slightly, which many plants and fish enjoy.
Shrimp-Focused Tanks
Neocaridina shrimp, like red cherry shrimp, do well on inert sand or gravel. Caridina shrimp, like crystal or bee shrimp, prefer an active soil that gently lowers pH and buffers KH. Choose a substrate made for shrimp if your goal is breeding sensitive varieties.
Goldfish and Diggers
Goldfish love to sift the bottom. Smooth sand or larger rounded gravel is best to prevent mouth injuries. Avoid sharp gravel. Keep depth shallower to reduce trapped debris and make cleaning easier.
African Cichlids
Rift lake cichlids from Lakes Malawi and Tanganyika prefer hard, alkaline water. Crushed coral, aragonite, or limestone-based sand helps raise and buffer pH and hardness. This supports their health and natural behavior.
Saltwater and Brackish Tanks
Marine tanks typically use aragonite sand. It helps maintain stable pH and alkalinity. Brackish tanks can use aragonite or inert sand depending on your target pH and the species you keep.
Bare-Bottom for Easy Cleaning
Some keepers skip substrate entirely. Bare-bottom tanks are great for quarantine, breeding, or high-bio-load setups because waste is easy to see and remove. The trade-off is a less natural look and less bacterial surface area compared to a tank with substrate.
Types of Substrates and What They Do
Each substrate has strengths and weaknesses. The best choice depends on your fish, plants, and maintenance habits. Here is a clear, beginner-friendly overview.
Inert Gravel
Inert gravel is rock that does not change pH or hardness. It comes in many colors and sizes. Smooth, rounded gravel is safe for bottom dwellers. It is easy to vacuum and works with undergravel filters if the pieces are coarse enough. It does not feed plants by itself, so rooted plants may need root tabs for nutrients. Choose gravel for simple community tanks, hardier plants, and if you like easy maintenance.
Silica Sand and Pool Filter Sand
Silica sand is smooth and soft for fish that like to dig or sift, such as corydoras and loaches. Pool filter sand is heavier and cleaner than play sand, so it is easier to rinse and less likely to blow around. Sand can compact if too deep, which may create low-oxygen spots. Keep it shallow or stir it gently during maintenance, and add rooted plants or Malaysian trumpet snails to keep it aerated. Sand is great for natural-looking scapes and fish that love soft bottoms.
Active Plant Soils (Aquasoil)
Plant soils are baked clays or volcanic granules charged with nutrients. They often lower pH and KH slightly, which many plants and soft-water fish prefer. They hold root nutrients and make planted tanks easier. Do not aggressively vacuum them because the granules can break down. Expect more initial cloudiness and a break-in period. Over time, plant soils become less active and may need replenishment or root tabs. Aquasoil is ideal for lush aquascapes and CO2 systems but also helps low-tech planted tanks.
Dirted or Enriched Layered Substrates
Some aquarists use a thin layer of organic garden soil or mineralized soil capped with sand or fine gravel. This can grow plants well at low cost. The risks are initial cloudiness, the need for careful capping, and a higher chance of ammonia spikes if disturbed. This method suits hobbyists who enjoy learning and are comfortable managing nutrients. If you try this, use plain, additive-free soil and a solid cap layer of 2 to 3 centimeters.
Crushed Coral, Aragonite, and Shell Substrates
These calcium carbonate substrates raise pH, KH, and GH. They are perfect for African cichlids, livebearers, some snails, and marine tanks. They are not suitable for soft-water fish or planted tanks that prefer lower pH. You can also place crushed coral in a filter bag to buffer water slowly without covering the entire bottom.
Specialty Clays, Laterite, and Additives
Laterite, clay balls, and similar additives provide iron and trace elements for plants. They are usually mixed into gravel or placed under a cap. Many modern aquasoils already include these nutrients, so you may not need extra layers unless you use inert gravel and want to boost root nutrition.
Size, Shape, and Texture
Grain size affects both looks and function. Fine sand looks natural and feels gentle for bottom fish. Medium gravel is easiest to clean. Coarse gravel works with undergravel filters because it allows good water flow. Always choose smooth, rounded grains for fish that dig or rest on the bottom. Sharp or rough pebbles can damage barbels or fins. Mixed grain sizes can trap debris, so pick one size when possible if easy cleaning is a priority.
Color and Look
Color is personal, but it also affects fish behavior. Dark substrates often make fish feel secure and bring out deep colors, especially in shy species. Light substrates can make tanks look brighter and larger but may cause some fish to wash out. Natural browns and blacks hide debris better than white sand. Painted gravel can chip; if you choose colored gravel, buy aquarium-safe products from trusted brands.
Depth and Layering
Depth depends on your goal. For sand, aim for about 2 to 5 centimeters. For gravel, use about 3 to 7 centimeters. For plant soils, 4 to 8 centimeters gives roots enough space. Deep sand beds are a special method used in some marine tanks; do not make freshwater sand too deep unless you know how to manage it. A gentle slope, shallow at the front and deeper at the back, creates depth in your aquascape and helps waste settle where you can reach it.
Layering can help when using enriched materials. Place a nutrient-rich layer below and cap it with sand or fine gravel to keep it from clouding the water. Keep the enriched layer thinner than the cap and avoid disturbing it during maintenance. If you prefer low risk and easy care, choose a single-layer inert substrate with root tabs for plants.
Water Chemistry Effects
Some substrates change pH, KH, and GH. Crushed coral and aragonite raise all three, which suits hard-water species. Active plant soils often lower pH and KH, which suits soft-water species and encourages plant growth. Inert gravel and silica sand do not change chemistry. If you keep sensitive fish or shrimp, match the substrate to their needs and test your water regularly with a liquid test kit. If your tap water is already very hard, an active soil will have a shorter life because it exhausts faster while buffering.
How Much Substrate to Buy
Estimate volume using this simple rule. Substrate volume in liters equals tank length times width times desired depth in centimeters, then divided by 1000. As an example, a 60 by 30 centimeter tank with a 5 centimeter depth needs 60 times 30 times 5, which equals 9000 cubic centimeters. Divide by 1000 to get 9 liters. For weight, gravel is around 1.5 kilograms per liter, sand about 1.6 kilograms per liter, and plant soil around 1.0 kilogram per liter. Buy a little extra in case you want a slight back-to-front slope.
Preparing and Adding Substrate
Rinse inert gravel and sand well before use. Place the substrate in a bucket and run water until it runs clear. Stir and pour off the cloudy water several times. For pool filter sand, rinsing is faster. For play sand, expect more rinsing. Do not rinse active plant soil unless the manufacturer clearly says so. Many plant soils are pre-rinsed or crumble if washed.
To add substrate without clouding, place a plate or plastic bag on the bottom and pour substrate gently on top. If you are filling a new tank, add water slowly onto the plate to avoid digging into the substrate. For layered setups, add the bottom layer first, level it out, and cap it carefully, keeping the cap thicker than the enriched layer.
Maintenance and Cleaning
Vacuum gravel with a siphon to remove trapped debris. Push the gravel vacuum into the substrate and let the pieces tumble for a second, then move on. For sand, hover the siphon just above the surface to lift waste without removing sand. For plant soils, vacuum lightly to remove loose debris only. Avoid deep stirring in planted tanks because you can damage roots.
Prevent compacted zones by keeping sand shallow, adding rooted plants, and gently stirring the top layer when you do water changes. If you see small bubbles from the substrate, that can be normal gas from decomposition. If the gas smells like rotten eggs when released, you may have anaerobic pockets. Reduce depth, improve water movement, and avoid large deep pockets of fine sand without plants or snails. Malaysian trumpet snails naturally burrow and help keep the substrate oxygenated.
Root-feeding plants benefit from root tabs placed near their base every few months if you use inert substrates. Replace or refresh plant soil after one to two years if plant growth declines and water chemistry is stable but roots look weak. Do maintenance consistently. A clean substrate helps prevent algae and keeps fish healthy.
Undergravel Filters and Substrate
If you plan to use an undergravel filter, choose coarse gravel that allows water to flow freely. Do not use sand of any kind with undergravel filters because it will clog the plates. Keep the gravel layer even, and vacuum regularly to prevent buildup. Undergravel filters work well in simple community tanks but are not ideal for heavy plant roots that can interfere with flow.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Many problems come from mismatching substrate to fish, plants, or water. A common mistake is using sharp gravel with bottom fish like corydoras or loaches. Choose fine, smooth sand for these species. Another mistake is using aragonite in soft-water planted tanks, which can fight your efforts to lower pH and harms sensitive plants.
New aquarists sometimes make the substrate too deep. This can trap waste, create low oxygen zones, and cause poor water quality. Keep depth moderate and matched to your goals. Overcleaning is another issue. In plant soils, heavy vacuuming breaks down granules and releases too much debris. Vacuum gently and mainly on the surface.
Do not use beach sand or construction materials that may carry contaminants or limestone unless you confirm they are aquarium-safe and inert. Be careful with cheap colored gravels that may have paint or coatings that flake. Always choose aquarium-grade products from reliable sources.
Sample Substrate Setups You Can Copy
For an easy community tank with livebearers and tetras, choose 3 to 5 centimeters of inert gravel or a shallow layer of pool filter sand. Add a few root tabs under heavy root feeders like swords, and vacuum lightly each week.
For a beginner planted aquascape, use 5 to 7 centimeters of active plant soil. Plant fast growers first to help control nutrients. Expect some initial water cloudiness. Do not deep vacuum. After a few months, add root tabs if heavy feeders slow down.
For a corydoras and loach tank, use 2 to 4 centimeters of fine, smooth sand. Avoid sharp grains. Stir the top gently during weekly water changes and keep the sand shallow to prevent compaction.
For goldfish, pick either larger smooth gravel that cannot be swallowed or a shallow fine sand bed. Keep the bed easy to clean, and do frequent water changes because goldfish produce a lot of waste.
For African cichlids, use aragonite sand or crushed coral to raise hardness and pH. Add rocks to create territories. Rinse well to reduce initial cloudiness. Test pH and KH to confirm the buffering effect.
For Neocaridina shrimp, choose inert sand or fine gravel. Add plenty of moss and hides. For Caridina shrimp, choose an active soil designed for shrimp that buffers to lower pH. Keep maintenance gentle and stable.
For a bare-bottom breeding or quarantine tank, skip substrate completely. Add a few safe decorations, like a sponge filter and a breeding mop, to give fish comfort. Clean the bottom daily with a siphon.
Budget-Friendly Tips
If you want to save money, buy pool filter sand instead of branded aquarium sand. It is clean, heavy, and usually safe. Always rinse well. For planted tanks on a budget, combine inert gravel with root tabs and a good liquid fertilizer instead of buying expensive plant soil. Start with hardy root feeders like crypts, swords, and val. Use driftwood and rocks to add visual interest so you do not need a deep substrate layer for impact, which reduces cost and weight.
Safety Notes You Should Know
Rinse substrates outside or in a tub with good drainage because fine dust can clog sinks. Wear a dust mask if you are rinsing very fine sand. Check magnets and metal tools away from the substrate to avoid dropping metal fragments into the tank. If you try decorative stones, test them first with a few drops of vinegar. If they fizz, they likely contain calcium carbonate, which raises hardness. That can be fine for cichlids but not for soft-water setups.
Aquascaping and Substrate Design
Use a front-to-back slope to create depth. Keep the front thin so you can see your fish, and build up the back to anchor tall plants and rocks. For terraces, you can use rocks or plastic mesh to hold slopes in place. When you place hardscape, put it directly on the glass or on a thin base layer so fish cannot undermine it and cause collapses. If you need to move plants, do it slowly to avoid pulling up the cap layer over enriched substrates.
How Substrate Supports Your Filter
Substrate increases the total surface area for beneficial bacteria. This helps the nitrogen cycle and stabilizes your tank. In a new tank, avoid deep cleaning during the first month to let bacteria grow. In established tanks, regular but gentle cleaning prevents detritus from building up while preserving the bacterial colonies. Good substrate choices make your filter’s job easier and your tank more forgiving.
When and How to Replace Substrate
Inert sand and gravel can last many years. You only need to top up or rinse portions if they become too dirty or start to compact. Plant soils slowly exhaust as plants use the nutrients. When plant growth fades and water chemistry is stable but roots look weak, you can refresh with new soil or root tabs. If you replace substrate, do it in sections over several weeks to protect your beneficial bacteria. Move fish gently and keep filters running to preserve the cycle.
Quick Decision Guide
If you want easy, low-maintenance, and a classic look, choose inert gravel. If you keep bottom-dwellers or want a natural riverbed feel, choose silica or pool filter sand. If you dream of a lush planted tank, choose active aquasoil. If you keep African cichlids or marine fish, choose aragonite-based sand. If you need the easiest cleaning for quarantine or breeding, go bare-bottom. Match the depth and maintenance to your choice, and you will be set for success.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to rinse substrate?
Rinse inert gravel and sand until water runs clear. Do not rinse most active plant soils unless the brand says it is safe to do so.
Will sand hurt my filter?
Fine sand can enter filters if the intake is too low. Keep the intake higher and use a sponge pre-filter. Do not use sand with undergravel filters.
Can I mix sand and gravel?
You can, but fine sand often sinks below gravel and can trap dirt. If you want the look of mixed textures, use them in separate areas or with hardscape borders.
How deep should my substrate be?
Sand is best at 2 to 5 centimeters, gravel at 3 to 7 centimeters, and plant soil at 4 to 8 centimeters. Keep it shallow if you want easy cleaning.
Is colored gravel safe?
Yes, if it is aquarium-safe and from a good brand. Avoid cheap, painted products that may flake or leach.
Do I need root tabs?
Use root tabs under heavy root feeders when using inert substrate. In aquasoil, add root tabs later if growth slows after nutrients are used up.
Will substrate change my pH?
Inert gravel and silica sand do not change pH. Aragonite and crushed coral raise pH. Active plant soils often lower pH. Test your water to confirm the effect.
Conclusion
The right substrate makes your aquarium healthier, easier to maintain, and more beautiful. Start by defining your goal. Choose inert gravel for simple community tanks, soft sand for bottom-dwellers, nutrient-rich aquasoil for planted scapes, and aragonite-based sands for hard-water or marine systems. Match grain size and depth to your fish and equipment. Rinse properly, add it gently, and maintain it with the right technique. With a clear plan and a few simple steps, you can build a substrate that supports your fish, grows your plants, and brings your aquascape to life.