We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Choosing the right water for your aquarium is one of the most important decisions you will make as a fish keeper. Many beginners wonder if rainwater is a natural, safe choice, while others stick with tap water because it is easy and available. The truth is that both can work, but each comes with very different risks and steps you must take to make it safe. In this guide, I will explain the differences between rainwater and tap water, how to make each one safe, and how to decide which is best for your fish, plants, and budget.
The Short Answer
If you are new to aquariums, tap water is usually the safest and easiest choice once you remove chlorine or chloramine with a conditioner. It is consistent, predictable, and fast to use. Rainwater can be used, but it is very soft, often acidic, and can pick up pollution, bacteria, and roof contaminants. If you use rainwater, you must filter it and add minerals back in before using it. A mix of rainwater and treated tap water often gives the best of both worlds, especially for soft-water tanks.
What Fish Need From Water
pH, GH, and KH in simple terms
pH tells you how acidic or basic your water is. Most community fish do well between 6.5 and 7.8. GH (general hardness) measures calcium and magnesium. Fish use these minerals for strong bones, osmoregulation, and overall health. KH (carbonate hardness) is your water’s buffering capacity. It keeps pH stable and prevents sudden swings. Low KH means your pH can crash quickly, which is dangerous for fish and beneficial bacteria.
TDS and stability
TDS stands for total dissolved solids. It is a quick way to estimate how much mineral and dissolved matter is in your water. A stable TDS, GH, and KH usually leads to stable fish health. Sudden changes are more harmful than numbers that are not “perfect.” Stability is more important than chasing exact pH values.
Tap Water For Aquariums
What is in tap water
Tap water is treated to be safe for people, not fish. It often contains chlorine or chloramine to kill germs. It may have trace metals from pipes, and sometimes it has nitrate or phosphate from the environment. On the positive side, it usually contains minerals like calcium and magnesium, which fish and plants need.
Pros of tap water
It is consistent. You can turn on the faucet and get the same general water profile every time. It is easy and quick. It has minerals that support fish health and plant growth. With a simple water conditioner, you can make it safe in minutes.
Cons of tap water
Chlorine and especially chloramine are toxic to fish and beneficial bacteria. Some tap water has high nitrate or phosphate. Some cities use very hard water with high KH, which is not ideal for soft-water fish like tetras, bettas, and dwarf shrimp. In older homes, there can be traces of metals like copper or lead, especially after long stagnation in pipes.
How to make tap water safe
Step 1: Use a good water conditioner that removes chlorine and chloramine. Check the label for chloramine if your city uses it. Most modern conditioners handle both.
Step 2: Match temperature to your tank. Sudden temperature changes stress fish.
Step 3: Test your tap water for pH, GH, KH, and nitrate. Knowing your baseline helps you plan your stocking and care.
Step 4: If heavy metals are a concern, run the water for a minute before collecting it, and consider using a carbon block or a conditioner that binds metals.
Step 5: If you have very hard water and want soft-water species, plan to mix your tap water with RO or rainwater, or use wood, botanicals, and CO2 in a planted tank to gently lower pH over time.
Common mistakes with tap water
Adding untreated water directly to the tank, which can kill fish and bacteria. Doing very large changes that shock fish with big swings in temperature or pH. Assuming all conditioners remove chloramine when some handle only chlorine. Ignoring high nitrate in tap water, which can fuel algae and stress fish.
Rainwater For Aquariums
What rainwater is like
Fresh rain is very soft and low in minerals. It often has near-zero GH and KH, and a slightly acidic pH. This sounds perfect for soft-water fish, but there is a catch. Rainwater easily picks up contaminants from the air and the surfaces it lands on. It can collect soot, dust, pollen, bacteria, mold spores, and chemicals from roofing materials. It can have low oxygen and can grow microbes if stored poorly.
Pros of rainwater
It is naturally soft and low in KH, great for species that prefer soft water. It is free once you set up collection. It gives you control over mineral content after you remineralize it. It can help reduce algae issues tied to hard tap water in some regions.
Cons of rainwater
It is too soft on its own. With nearly zero KH, pH can swing fast, risking a crash that harms fish and filter bacteria. It may be contaminated by roof materials like asphalt, zinc-coated gutters, or old lead paint. It can contain pesticides, soot, or other pollutants depending on your location. It needs careful collection, storage, filtration, and remineralization. It is weather-dependent, so it is hard to rely on year-round without a storage system.
How to collect rainwater safely
Use a clean catchment surface. Avoid roofs with tar, fresh asphalt shingles, old lead flashing, or copper gutters. Metal roofs and modern ceramic tile are better options. Do not collect the first rainfall after a long dry spell. Install a first-flush diverter to discard the initial dirty portion of rainfall. Collect water in food-grade, opaque containers to block light and reduce algae growth. Keep lids tightly sealed to keep out insects and debris. Label containers and keep them separate from chemicals and fuels.
Treating rainwater before use
Pre-filter through a fine mesh or cloth to remove debris. Run it through activated carbon to reduce organic pollutants and odors. If contamination risk is high, consider UV sterilization or bring to a brief boil and cool completely before use. After treatment, always remineralize. Pure rainwater lacks the minerals fish and plants need, and without KH your pH is unstable.
Remineralization basics
Your goal is to add back GH for calcium and magnesium, and KH for stable pH. You can use commercial remineralization salts made for RO or distilled water. These are beginner-friendly and come with dosing instructions. For a soft, planted community tank, a common target is GH 4 to 6 and KH 2 to 4. For shrimp like Neocaridina, target GH 6 to 8 and KH 3 to 5. For soft-water fish like bettas and tetras, GH 3 to 6 and KH 1 to 3 works well, but always aim for stability.
A simple remineralization example
If you have 20 liters of rainwater, use a product labeled “GH/KH+” and dose according to the package to reach GH 5 and KH 3. Stir well, test with a liquid test kit, and adjust slowly. If your pH lands around 6.8 to 7.2 in a low-tech planted tank, that is usually safe for community fish. Do not guess. Always test.
Storage and stability
Store rainwater in a cool, dark place in sealed, food-grade containers. Use it within a few weeks to reduce microbial growth. Before use, stir or aerate for an hour to raise oxygen. Always test GH, KH, and pH after remineralizing. Keep a log so your results are repeatable.
Common mistakes with rainwater
Using pure, untreated rainwater in the tank. This leads to pH crashes and sick fish. Collecting from unsafe surfaces or open barrels that breed insects and bacteria. Skipping carbon or UV treatment in polluted areas. Forgetting to test. Assuming “natural” means “safe.”
Mixing Rainwater and Tap Water: The Middle Path
Why mixing helps
Mixing is a practical way to lower hard tap water to a gentler profile while keeping some KH for stability. It also reduces the risk that comes with using 100 percent rainwater. Many hobbyists mix to reach a target KH and GH, then leave the rest to regular, small water changes.
A simple mixing plan
Step 1: Test your tap water. For example, KH 10, GH 12, pH 7.8. Step 2: Prepare treated rainwater with no minerals added yet. Step 3: Start with a 50 to 50 mix and test. If the result is KH 5 and GH 6, you might be close to a good community target. Step 4: Fine-tune by adding a small amount of remineralizer to tweak GH or KH as needed. Keep notes so you can repeat the mix next time with confidence.
Example targets for common setups
Community fish like guppies, mollies, platies, and many tetras do well around GH 6 to 10 and KH 3 to 6. Soft-water species like cardinal tetras and dwarf cichlids prefer GH 3 to 6 and KH 1 to 3. African rift lake cichlids need much higher values, often GH 12 to 20 and KH 8 to 12. For those, tap water might be ideal, and rainwater is not needed.
Special Cases and Species
Soft-water fish and shrimp
Bettas, rasboras, and many tetras prefer softer, more acidic water. Rainwater mixed with tap or used with remineralization is a good way to hit those targets while keeping KH stable. Caridina shrimp prefer very soft water with low KH, but they also need precise minerals. Many shrimp keepers use RO or rainwater plus a dedicated shrimp mineral mix for consistency.
Hard-water fish and livebearers
Livebearers like guppies, mollies, and swordtails thrive in hard, alkaline water. Tap water is usually perfect for them. Rainwater is often unnecessary and can make the water too soft, causing health issues.
Planted tanks and CO2
Plants like stable minerals and carbonates. Very low KH can cause pH swings when CO2 is used. Aim for at least KH 2 to 3 in CO2 tanks to keep pH stable. If you want softer water for plant nutrient uptake, mix rainwater with tap but do not let KH fall to zero unless you are very experienced and monitor pH carefully.
Testing: The Non-Negotiable Step
What to test and how often
Test pH, GH, KH, and nitrate weekly at first. Test ammonia and nitrite during cycling or after big changes. If you use tap water, test for chlorine or chloramine when your water company changes treatment or after heavy maintenance. If you use rainwater, test GH, KH, and pH every time you mix a new batch, and keep a record.
Interpreting results and red flags
If KH is below 1, pH can crash. If GH is below 2 in community tanks, fish and plants may struggle. If nitrate is over 40 ppm in the tank, increase water changes or adjust feeding. If pH changes more than 0.4 in a day, increase KH or reduce CO2 or organic load. If ammonia or nitrite is not zero in a mature tank, your biofilter is stressed, often from a sudden pH swing or recent big change.
Troubleshooting and FAQs
My water turned cloudy after a change
Cloudiness after a water change is usually a bacterial bloom or precipitated minerals. If you used rainwater without remineralizing, the pH may have shifted and stressed the filter bacteria. Test pH and KH, and stabilize with a small dose of KH buffer or a partial water change with conditioned tap. If you mixed waters with very different mineral profiles, clouds can be harmless carbonate precipitation and will clear in a day or two.
What is a pH crash and how do I stop it
A pH crash is a sudden drop in pH when KH is too low to buffer acids made by fish waste and the biofilter. Fish may gasp, hide, or die. Stop feeding, do a gentle partial water change with water that has some KH, and increase aeration. In the future, maintain KH of at least 2 to 3 for community tanks and avoid using pure, unbuffered rainwater.
I used rainwater and got an ammonia spike
Very low pH can slow your biofilter, but sudden pH changes can also harm it. If your pH rose or dropped quickly during the water change, the bacteria may have been shocked. Stabilize KH and pH, add bottled bacteria if needed, and keep changes small and frequent until the filter recovers.
Is boiling tap water enough to make it safe
No. Boiling may remove some chlorine, but it does not remove chloramine or metals. Always use a water conditioner that handles chlorine and chloramine. Boiling is not practical or reliable for aquarium use.
What about distilled or RO water
Distilled or RO water is like clean rainwater with almost no minerals. It is safe only after you remineralize it. Many keepers prefer RO with remineralization over rainwater because it is consistent year-round. The same remineralization rules apply.
Cost, Effort, and Sustainability
Time and gear
Tap water requires a conditioner, a thermometer, and a test kit. It is fast. Rainwater requires a clean roof or catchment, first-flush diverter, food-grade storage, carbon filtration or UV, and mineral salts. It takes more time and planning. If you enjoy the process and want soft water for specific species, rainwater can be great. If you want simple and reliable, tap water is your friend.
Environmental angle
Using rainwater can reduce reliance on treated municipal water, which is nice for the environment. However, improper storage or contamination can lead to fish losses, which is wasteful and discouraging. The most sustainable path is the one you can maintain safely long term. For many, that means tap water with careful conditioning and moderate water changes.
Quick Decision Guide
For absolute beginners
Use tap water plus a good conditioner. Test your water and choose fish that fit your tap water profile. Keep water changes small and regular. Avoid rainwater until you are comfortable with testing and stability.
For intermediate keepers
If your tap water is very hard, mix it with conditioned rainwater or RO to reach your target GH and KH. Remineralize rainwater if mixing drops KH too low. Keep a log so your results are repeatable.
For advanced or species-specific tanks
For soft-water blackwater biotopes or sensitive shrimp, use rainwater or RO with precise remineralization. Use carbon or UV treatment, maintain clean storage, and test every batch. Keep KH low but not zero unless you understand and can manage the risks.
Practical Tips You Can Use Today
Know your numbers
Before changing anything, measure your tap water’s pH, GH, KH, and nitrate. This determines your next steps and fish choices.
Condition consistently
Always use a conditioner for tap water. If your city uses chloramine, make sure your conditioner breaks the chlorine-ammonia bond and detoxifies the ammonia component.
Remineralize rainwater
Never use pure rainwater in your tank. Add minerals until GH and KH are within safe ranges, then test again after mixing with tank water.
Go slow
Change 10 to 25 percent of water per week rather than large, infrequent changes. Fish and bacteria prefer small, steady adjustments.
Watch your fish
Fish are great indicators. If they clamp fins, gasp, or hide after a water change, test immediately. Correct KH and temperature first, then look at pH and ammonia.
Myth Busting
Rainwater is natural, so it must be best
Natural does not mean safe. In nature, huge bodies of water buffer changes. In a home aquarium, low KH rainwater can cause extreme pH swings and wipe out your filter bacteria if not managed carefully.
Tap water ruins aquariums
Tap water works beautifully when treated and matched with suitable fish. Many stunning aquariums run for years on conditioned tap water with no issues.
Fish will adapt to any water if you drip acclimate long enough
Acclimation helps with sudden changes, but long-term health requires appropriate GH, KH, and pH. Drip acclimation cannot make soft-water fish thrive in very hard water, or vice versa.
Example Setup Scenarios
Beginner community tank with tap water
20 to 40 gallon tank with livebearers and hardy tetras. Treat tap water with a conditioner, keep GH 6 to 10 and KH 3 to 6, do 20 percent weekly changes, and keep nitrate under 40 ppm. This setup is easy and stable.
Soft-water community with rainwater mix
Mixed rasboras, small tetras, and a betta. Use 50 percent treated tap and 50 percent treated and remineralized rainwater. Target GH 4 to 6, KH 2 to 3, and pH around 6.8 to 7.2. Add botanicals for tannins if desired. Test weekly for stability.
Planted tank with CO2
Use mostly tap water if it is not extreme. Keep KH 3 to 4 for pH stability with CO2. If tap water is very hard, mix in some rainwater but keep KH above 2. Focus on stable CO2 and nutrients.
Safety Checklist Before Using Rainwater
Collection and storage
Safe roof or catchment, first flush diverter installed, food-grade sealed barrels, no chemical exposure, water stored in the dark and kept covered.
Treatment
Prefilter debris, carbon filtration, optional UV or brief boil if contamination risk is high, cool to tank temperature, aerate, and then remineralize.
Testing
Confirm GH and KH targets. Check pH after remineralization. Keep batch notes so you can reproduce results every time.
Conclusion
Both rainwater and tap water can support a healthy aquarium, but they demand different levels of care. Tap water, when treated for chlorine and chloramine, is simple, consistent, and usually the best choice for beginners. Rainwater can be excellent for soft-water species, but only after proper collection, filtration, and careful remineralization to restore GH and KH. Mixing the two is often the easiest way to tailor your water to your fish without risking instability.
Whichever path you choose, remember that stability beats perfection. Test your water, change it in small amounts, and keep detailed notes. Learn your tap baseline, and if you use rainwater, treat it like a raw ingredient that needs preparation. Do this, and your fish will reward you with color, activity, and long, healthy lives.