We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Walk into a pet store and you may see tanks full of brilliant neon “blueberry,” “strawberry,” or “jellybean” fish. They look stunning at first glance, and it is easy to imagine how they could brighten a home aquarium. But many of these animals did not naturally come in those colors. They were dyed. As an aquarium specialist, I want to explain clearly what dyed fish are, how to spot them, why many responsible stores refuse to sell them, and how you can get gorgeous color in your tank the healthy, ethical way. If you already bought a dyed fish, I will also share steps to care for it with compassion.
What Are Dyed Fish?
Dyed fish are fish that have been artificially colored to appear brighter or to show patterns they would never have in nature. The color is not produced by genetics, diet, or good care. It is added through invasive or harsh methods after the fish has already grown, and it often fades with time or stress.
These fish are sometimes sold under fun, fruity names that hint at the artificial process. The goal is to attract attention and create impulse buys. Unfortunately, the way the color is added often causes pain, long-term stress, and higher rates of illness and death.
Common Names You Might See
You may see names such as painted glassfish, jellybean parrot cichlids, blueberry or strawberry tetras, colored skirt tetras, or fruit cichlids. These names are a red flag that the color is not natural. Common targets include glassfish, white skirt tetras, parrot cichlids, some loaches, and occasionally cories and mollies.
How They Are Dyed
There are three common methods. Injection involves using a needle to push dye under the skin in many small punctures. This can create patterns or patches of color. It also breaks the fish’s protective slime coat, opening the door to infection. Dipping involves removing the slime coat with a chemical, then soaking the fish in dye, and sometimes applying another chemical bath to encourage the skin to take up the color. Tattooing uses a device to etch or print patterns onto the fish with pigments, similar to a skin tattoo on a human, but on a small animal with very thin tissue and no choice in the matter.
All of these processes cause stress and discomfort. They can lead to high mortality during or shortly after the procedure. Even when fish survive, many show long-term health problems and reduced life expectancy. The color may fade quickly, especially under good care, which can be confusing for new hobbyists who expected a permanent bright hue.
Some fish are not dyed but are fed hormones to temporarily change coloration. That is a different practice, but it also raises welfare and honesty concerns. It is another reason to ask questions and buy from transparent, ethical sources.
Why We Do Not Sell Dyed Fish
Health and Welfare Costs
We do not sell dyed fish because the procedures used to color them are harmful. The injection and tattoo processes cause pain and pierce the skin and scales. Dipping strips away the slime coat that shields fish from pathogens. These fish often arrive weakened, stressed, and more likely to become sick. Even with careful quarantine, they have a higher risk of infection, fin rot, and opportunistic diseases. Many have shortened lifespans.
Our goal is to promote healthy, happy aquariums. Selling animals that were harmed to make them look more “marketable” goes against that mission. We prefer to support suppliers who breed or raise fish with care, not those who rely on cosmetic procedures that put profits above welfare.
It Misleads New Keepers
Bright, dyed colors can fade after purchase, especially as the fish heals and regrows a healthy slime coat. Many newcomers think they did something wrong when the fish loses color, which can lead to frustration, blame, and even giving up on the hobby. We want your first experiences to build confidence, not confusion. Honest color from natural genetics and good care will stay and even improve over time.
Hidden Disease Risk to Your Tank
Fish that have been processed are more likely to carry infections and to be immunocompromised. Bringing a dyed fish into a community tank can expose all of your pets to diseases. While good quarantine helps, the initial risk is unnecessary. A responsible store minimizes this risk by avoiding high-stress, high-mortality supply chains.
Ethics and Industry Standards
Many hobby organizations, fish clubs, and responsible retailers discourage or ban the sale of dyed fish. Some regions and stores have firm policies against physically altering fish for cosmetic reasons. Even where it is not explicitly illegal, the practice conflicts with the growing focus on animal welfare and transparency. We believe the hobby should celebrate the true beauty of fish through ethical breeding and excellent care, not through painful shortcuts.
How to Identify Dyed Fish at the Store
Unnatural Colors for That Species
Start with a quick mental check. Does that species naturally come in electric green, hot pink, or bright purple? If not, be cautious. White skirt tetras do not naturally glow blue or cotton-candy pink without genetic modification. Glassfish are transparent; they do not naturally have neon streaks. Parrot cichlids can be orange or red, but they do not naturally come in rainbow pastels.
Color Pattern Clues
Look closely at how the color sits on the fish. Dyed color can look blotchy, patchy, or too uniform on the body but missing in the fins and eyes. You may see streaks or oddly sharp edges where dye was injected. Tattooed designs sometimes look like hearts, stripes, or dots that do not match natural patterning.
Physical Signs of Procedures
Under bright light you may notice tiny pinpricks, missing scales, inflamed patches, or a dull, rough appearance where the protective slime coat was damaged. Fins may be frayed or the fish may be breathing faster than normal. These are signs of stress and possible poor handling.
Fading Over Time
If the store admits that the color fades, or if online reviews mention rapid fading, you are likely looking at dyed fish or hormone-enhanced fish. True genetic color and natural pigment from good care should not vanish in a few weeks.
Ask the Right Questions
You can politely ask, “Are these fish artificially colored?” or “Are these dyed, injected, or tattooed?” If staff say the fish are “just colored” or avoid answering, be cautious. Ask if the fish are genetically colored, like legally sold fluorescent strains that pass their color to offspring, or if they were physically altered. A good store will be clear and honest about sources and methods.
Dyed Fish vs. GloFish and Other Color Varieties
GloFish Explained
GloFish are genetically modified fish that carry fluorescent protein genes. They are not dyed, injected, or tattooed. Their color is part of their DNA and is passed to their offspring. It does not fade under normal care. While some aquarists prefer to keep only natural species, GloFish are different from dyed fish because they are not altered through painful procedures after birth. If you are considering fluorescent fish, learn the regulations in your area and decide based on your own ethics and tank goals.
Selective Breeding and Natural Color Pops
Many beautiful fish come in stunning colors thanks to careful, long-term selective breeding that does not involve invasive procedures. Guppies, endlers, bettas, angelfish, rainbows, and cichlids show amazing natural and cultured color morphs. Albino and leucistic forms, metallic scales, and long-finned strains are common and ethically produced. These fish reward good care by becoming even more vibrant over time.
Hormone-Enhanced Fish
Some fish are given hormones to temporarily boost colors, especially before sale. The effect fades and can stress the fish. This practice is not the same as dyeing, but it still misleads buyers and can impact health. If a fish looks unusually intense compared to the species norm, ask about hormone use and choose sellers who are transparent and avoid such methods.
Alternatives to Dyed Fish: Beautiful and Ethical Choices
Vibrant Species for Small Tanks
If you keep a nano aquarium, look for ember tetras, neon tetras, cardinal tetras, chili rasboras, celestial pearl danios, endlers, or guppies. Even a small group of these fish can glow with natural color. Pygmy corydoras add movement on the bottom and do well in peaceful communities. Choose species that match your tank size and water parameters.
Showstoppers for Medium to Large Tanks
For larger aquariums, consider rainbowfish such as Melanotaenia boesemani, angelfish in various patterns, electric blue acaras, Congo tetras, or German blue rams. These fish provide incredible natural color when kept in proper water conditions and varied diets. Some, like discus and rams, need more experience and stable water, so plan your stocking around your skill level.
Invertebrates and Plants Add Color
Shrimp such as cherry, fire red, and blue dream add bold pops of color and help with algae control in planted tanks. Nerite snails provide unique shell patterns. Plants like Ludwigia, Alternanthera, and red tiger lotus bring rich reds and purples when given good light and nutrients. A planted aquascape can be as colorful as any reef, without altering your fish.
How to Bring Out Natural Color the Right Way
Stable, Clean Water
Healthy fish show their best colors in clean, stable water. Keep ammonia and nitrite at zero and nitrates low through regular water changes. Cycle your tank before adding fish so your biofilter is established. Match pH, hardness, and temperature to your species. Stability reduces stress, which is the number one color killer.
Quality Diet with Color-Boosters
Feed a varied diet that includes high-quality pellets or flakes plus frozen or live foods. Ingredients rich in carotenoids and astaxanthin can enhance reds, oranges, and yellows. Spirulina helps with natural blues and greens in some species. Rotate foods to cover all nutrients and avoid overfeeding. Good nutrition keeps pigments vibrant and immune systems strong.
Comfortable Environment
Create a tank layout that helps fish feel safe. Add plants, wood, rocks, and caves to break sight lines. Provide the right group size for shoaling fish so they do not feel exposed. Choose tankmates that will not nip fins or bully. A stress-free fish will show deeper, richer color than a stressed fish in a bare tank.
Lighting and Background
Use full-spectrum lighting that supports your plants and brings out natural colors without being harsh. A dark background and darker substrate often make fish appear more saturated. Avoid sudden lighting changes that startle fish. A consistent day-night cycle supports healthy behavior and color.
Avoid Stress
Acclimate new fish slowly. Keep stocking levels reasonable. Maintain the filter and avoid sudden changes in temperature or chemistry. Handle maintenance calmly and avoid tapping the glass. Many color issues disappear as soon as fish feel secure and the environment stops changing.
If You Already Own a Dyed Fish
Immediate Steps
If you realize you purchased a dyed fish, focus on comfort and health. If possible, quarantine the fish in a separate, cycled tank for a few weeks. Watch for signs of infection such as frayed fins, white patches, lethargy, or rapid breathing. Keep water very clean and stable. Offer high-quality food and reduce stress with plants or shelter. Treat illness based on symptoms rather than medicating “just in case.”
Realistic Expectations
The added color is likely to fade, sometimes quickly. The fish may have a shorter lifespan than normal for its species. That is not your fault. Your job now is to give the best care you can and let the fish live out its life comfortably. Many dyed fish can still become wonderful pets with gentle handling and consistent care.
When to Seek Help
If you see clear signs of bacterial or fungal infection, or if the fish stops eating, ask an experienced aquarist or aquatic veterinarian for guidance. Provide water test results and a photo if you can. Avoid stacking multiple medications at once. Good water quality and reduced stress are often as important as any treatment.
How the Trade Is Changing
Consumer Power Matters
Stores respond to what hobbyists ask for. When customers choose not to buy dyed fish and ask for ethically sourced alternatives, suppliers pay attention. You can support positive change simply by asking, “Were these fish artificially colored?” and then buying from transparent stores.
Certifications and Better Suppliers
More breeders and farms now focus on captive-bred stock, disease screening, and humane practices. As buyers, we can favor these suppliers. Healthy, naturally colored fish live longer, look better, and make the hobby more rewarding. The future of fishkeeping is bright when we reward good practices.
Our Promise
We do not sell dyed or tattooed fish, and we avoid hormone-enhanced stock. We quarantine, we ask tough questions of suppliers, and we educate customers honestly. The goal is to help you build a thriving, beautiful aquarium with fish that can show their true colors for years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do dyed fish live shorter lives?
Yes, on average dyed fish have higher stress and disease rates and often shorter lifespans. The severity depends on the method used, the species, and the fish’s condition after the procedure. Good care can help, but it cannot undo the harm already done.
Is dyeing ever harmless?
No. Injection, dipping, and tattooing all damage the slime coat and skin and cause stress. Even when fish survive the process, it is not a neutral cosmetic change. It is a painful procedure with real risks.
Can dye transfer to tankmates?
No, the color itself does not rub off or dye other fish. However, dyed fish may carry pathogens due to the procedures. That is why quarantine is important and why many aquarists avoid bringing dyed fish into established communities.
Are painted glassfish the same as glass catfish?
No, they are different species. Painted glassfish are usually Indian glassfish that have been dyed. Glass catfish are a different transparent species that are not typically dyed. Always check the scientific name and look for signs of artificial color.
What about colored invertebrates or painted decorations?
Some invertebrates, corals, and even hermit shells are artificially dyed or painted. Avoid these items whenever possible. Choose naturally colorful species and safe, aquarium-grade decorations that do not rely on animal harm or misleading practices.
Conclusion
Dyed fish may look exciting in the moment, but the cost behind those colors is far too high. The procedures that create those hues cause stress, pain, and a higher risk of disease and early death. They mislead new hobbyists and add risk to community tanks. That is why we choose not to sell them. Instead, we celebrate fish that glow with natural beauty and respond to good care, smart diets, and thoughtful tank design.
You can build a tank full of honest color by choosing the right species, maintaining stable water, offering varied foods, and creating a comfortable, planted environment. If you already have a dyed fish, give it the best care you can and focus on comfort. As a community, when we vote with our wallets and support ethical sources, we make the hobby better for everyone—most of all, for the fish.