We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
So you love the idea of a puffer fish but you also want a peaceful tropical freshwater community tank. Can those two goals live together? Yes, with careful species choice and setup. While most puffers are nippy or need special water, there are a couple of species that can work in a true freshwater community. This guide explains which puffers to pick, which to avoid, and how to plan a tank where everyone thrives. The tips below are written for new hobbyists in clear, simple language, but are detailed enough to help you make good decisions the first time.
First, a reality check: can puffers live in community tanks?
Puffers are smart, curious, and often territorial. Many species nip fins or even bite chunks from tank mates. Some need brackish water, others grow huge, and many are best in species-only tanks. Still, there are two freshwater species that are known to be more community-friendly when kept correctly. If you pick the right puffer and plan your tank around its needs—especially space, group size, hard-shelled foods, and fast tank mates—you can enjoy a lively community with a puffer as the star.
Puffer species you should not choose for a freshwater community tank
Brackish puffers to avoid in “freshwater” communities
Some popular pet-store puffers are not true freshwater fish long-term. The Green Spotted Puffer (Dichotomyctere nigroviridis) and the Figure Eight Puffer (Dichotomyctere ocellatus) need brackish water as they mature. They are also feisty and often nip. They can survive for a while in freshwater, which is why you see them in freshwater shops, but they will not thrive. If your goal is a tropical freshwater community, do not pick these species.
Large or highly aggressive freshwater puffers
Fahaka Puffers (Pao fahaka), Mbu Puffers (Potamotrygon mbu), and similar big species are amazing fish, but they are not community-safe. They grow large, can be very aggressive, and will attack tank mates. These fish are best in huge, single-specimen tanks with experienced keepers.
Ambush or predatory species
Species like the Palembang Puffer (Pao palembangensis), Pao suvattii, and similar ambush puffers are sit-and-wait predators that bite when a fish passes too close. They are not suitable for community tanks. Even small, shy ambush puffers can cause serious damage to other fish.
The two best options for freshwater community setups
South American Puffer (Colomesus asellus)
Often called the South American Puffer (SAP) or Amazon Puffer, this is one of the very few puffers that can fit into a community tank. They stay small (about 2.5–3 inches), are active swimmers, and are fast. They are less likely to fixate on a single tank mate. Kept in a proper group and in a big enough tank with good flow, SAPs often ignore quick schooling fish and focus on hunting snails and exploring.
These puffers still have beaks that can overgrow if you do not provide hard foods. They also come in wild-caught most of the time and may carry internal worms, so quarantine is important. Still, with planning they are the most reliable community-friendly puffer for freshwater.
Congo Spotted Puffer (Tetraodon schoutedeni)
Tetraodon schoutedeni, sometimes called the Spotted Congo Puffer, is another true freshwater puffer that can work in a community with care. They grow to about 3–4 inches, are intelligent, and are known to be among the more peaceful Tetraodon species. Good aquascaping and careful tank mate choice are still needed, but many hobbyists successfully keep small groups of schoutedeni with active midwater fish that do not have long fins.
This species appreciates calmer flow than SAPs and often does well in a well-structured aquascape with wood, plants, and many sight breaks. As with all puffers, provide crunchy foods to manage their teeth, and avoid slow or long-finned tank mates.
Tank size and group size recommendations
For South American Puffers
Plan for a group of at least six SAPs. This spreads out any mild aggression and keeps them busy with each other rather than your other fish. A 55-gallon (200 liters) tank is a common starting point for a group, with a 4-foot (120 cm) footprint to provide long swim space and room for territories. Larger is always better, especially if you want a robust community around them. SAPs are quick swimmers and appreciate open areas to zoom through as well as plant thickets to rest in.
For Tetraodon schoutedeni
Schoutedeni can be kept singly, in pairs, or in small groups. Keeping a group spreads attention and can reduce stress, but you need enough room and many hiding places. A 40-gallon breeder can work for a pair or a small group of 3–4, but a 55-gallon gives you more safety and more options for tank mates. Start with a group and rehome extra individuals if any bullying becomes persistent. Avoid cramming; space and sight breaks are your best tools.
Water parameters and temperature
South American Puffer parameters
Temperature around 24–27°C (75–81°F), pH 6.4–7.5, and soft to medium hardness are good targets. Stability matters more than chasing exact numbers. These are river fish and appreciate clean, well-oxygenated water with low ammonia and nitrite (zero) and low nitrate (ideally under 20 ppm). Big weekly water changes help, and extra oxygen keeps them active and healthy.
Tetraodon schoutedeni parameters
Temperature around 24–27°C (75–81°F), pH 6.8–7.8, and moderate hardness are suitable. They come from the Congo basin and do well in neutral to slightly alkaline water. Again, stable, clean water is the key. If your community fish prefer similar conditions (for example, Congo tetras), you can build a regional-themed tank that suits everyone.
Aquascape and filtration tips
Layout that reduces aggression
Design the tank with both open water and many sight breaks. Use tall plants, driftwood, rock piles, and floating plants to break up lines of sight so fish can escape attention. Arrange decorations so there are at least three distinct zones: an open swim lane across the front, a dense plant or wood area, and a shaded section. Puffers like to explore and perch, and these zones give them options.
Flow and oxygen
SAPs especially enjoy moderate flow, which keeps them active and reduces boredom nipping. Use a canister filter or a strong hang-on-back with a spray bar or directional flow nozzles to create circulation. Schoutedeni prefer moderate to gentle flow with good oxygenation. Add an airstone or keep your filter output rippling the surface to maintain high oxygen, which also helps your biofilter and reduces stress.
Substrate and maintenance
Fine sand is a safe choice. It is easy on puffer bellies and good for catfish tank mates if you choose them. Avoid sharp gravel. Keep the tank clean, vacuum debris weekly, and do regular water changes. Puffers are messy eaters, and leftover meaty foods can foul the water if you do not keep up with maintenance.
Feeding puffers in a community tank
Diet basics
Puffers are carnivores that need meaty foods, not flakes. Offer a varied diet of frozen or live foods like bloodworms, blackworms, earthworms, mysis shrimp, krill, and chopped shrimp. Rotate foods to avoid nutritional gaps. Avoid feeder fish due to disease and poor nutrition. Train your puffer to take food from tongs so you can target-feed and be sure they eat their share.
Beak and tooth management
All puffers have fused teeth (a “beak”) that can overgrow. Prevent problems by giving hard-shelled foods several times a week. For small puffers, pond or bladder snails and ramshorn snails are ideal. You can culture snails in a small separate tank. For schoutedeni, you can also use small clams, crushed mussel, or thin crab legs. Watch for signs of overgrown teeth such as dropping food, difficulty biting, or weight loss. Prevention is much easier than trimming.
Feeding without chaos
In mixed tanks, fast schooling fish may steal food. Feed in multiple spots at once. Offer community fish a small pinch on one side, then target-feed the puffers with tongs on the other. Feed the puffers first if they are shy, or last if they tend to harass others at feeding time. Remove uneaten meaty food after 10–15 minutes to protect water quality.
Tank mates that tend to work
Good companions for South American Puffers
Pick fast, alert, midwater fish with short fins. Examples include larger tetras like rummy-nose, lemon, and ember tetras (in decent numbers); rasboras like harlequins and scissortails; and some rainbowfish species that stay medium-sized. Pencilfish and hatchetfish can also work in a covered tank since they jump. The goal is to avoid slow, long-finned fish and to choose active species that do not invite nipping.
Good companions for Tetraodon schoutedeni
For a regional feel, Congo tetras make great midwater companions. They are fast and enjoy similar water. Add robust bottom dwellers such as Synodontis catfish (smaller species) if the tank is big and structured with hiding places. Some peaceful barbs and rainbows can work, but avoid very boisterous or fin-nippy varieties that may stress the puffers. Always watch the first few weeks closely and be ready to rehome any problem fish.
Fish to avoid with puffers
Avoid long-finned fish like bettas, fancy guppies, angelfish, and veil varieties. Do not mix with slow-moving species that invite bites, such as discus in small tanks. Many loaches and some barbs can become either bullies or victims, so choose carefully. Plecos can be risky; some individuals are fine, but others get their fins nipped or rasp on puffers at night. Corydoras can work in some setups, but nipped fins are common. If you try them, make sure the tank is large, the puffer group is well-fed, and there are many hiding places.
Invertebrates: snacks, not pets
Puffers eat snails and shrimp. If you love your shrimp and snails, do not add a puffer. If you want snails as a cleanup crew in a puffer tank, assume they will be hunted. Use nerites only if you accept that some may be harassed; even thick shells are not a guarantee. Many puffer keepers instead grow snail cultures in a separate tank and add them as food.
Behavior and troubleshooting
Reading puffer body language
A calm puffer explores, watches you, and shows smooth, confident swimming. Warning signs include persistent chasing, repeated tail nips on other fish, clamped fins, hiding all day, or rapid breathing. Stress stripes or very dull coloration can also signal a problem. Learn your puffer’s normal routine so you can spot changes early.
Reducing nipping
Use larger groups of puffers (for SAPs) and larger shoals of tank mates so no single fish is targeted. Provide line-of-sight breaks so fish can avoid each other. Keep the puffers well-fed on interesting, crunchy foods; boredom increases nipping. Make sure there is enough space and that you are not overcrowding the midwater where traffic jams cause bites.
If aggression shows up
Start by rearranging decor to reset territories. Increase feeding frequency slightly while maintaining water quality. Add more visual barriers. If a single individual is the problem, consider moving it temporarily to a breeder box or rehoming it. Sometimes one puffer has a personality that does not fit a community. It is better to remove the bully than to risk ongoing injuries.
Quarantine and health essentials
Quarantine and deworming
Many puffers arrive with internal parasites. Always quarantine new puffers for at least four weeks in a separate tank. Watch for white stringy poop, weight loss, or poor appetite. Common treatments include praziquantel and levamisole used in cycles according to product directions. Do not mix multiple medications at once unless instructions from a vet or experienced keeper advise it. After quarantine, move the puffer using a container of water, not a dry net.
Safe handling and “puffing”
Do not force your puffer to puff. It is a stress reaction and can be harmful, especially if they swallow air. When you must move a puffer, use a cup or plastic container underwater so the fish stays submerged. Keep the move calm and quick. Cover the tank well; curious puffers can jump when startled.
Example stocking plans
Example 55-gallon South American Puffer community
Start with a group of six SAPs. Add a school of 20 rummy-nose tetras for midwater motion and color. Choose 12 harlequin rasboras for contrast. Consider 8 hatchetfish for the top, but only if your lid is tight. For the bottom, you can try a small group of dwarf chain loaches or a few robust catfish, but be ready to remove them if nipping occurs. Aquascape with dense plants at the back and sides, wood arches to break sight lines, and an open swimming lane. Set moderate flow and high oxygen. Feed a mix of frozen bloodworms, blackworms, mysis, and cultured snails several times per week. Quarantine all new fish, especially the puffers.
Example 40-breeder Tetraodon schoutedeni community
Keep a group of three schoutedeni with significant hardscape: driftwood, caves, and plants to create multiple territories. Add 12–16 Congo tetras as active, fast companions. A small group of peaceful Synodontis (like S. lucipinnis) can work if there are caves and you keep the tank clean. Maintain moderate flow with strong oxygen and neutral to slightly alkaline water. Target-feed the puffers clams, snails, worms, and quality frozen foods. Observe for any aggression and be ready to separate individuals if needed. If you see fin nips on the tetras, increase feeding variety and sight breaks.
Frequently asked quick answers
Can pea puffers live in a community tank?
Pea puffers (Carinotetraodon travancoricus) are tiny but very feisty. Most do best in species-only setups. In rare cases, experienced keepers succeed with a heavily planted larger tank and fast schooling fish, but the risk of nipping is high. If you are new, keep pea puffers in their own dedicated tank.
Do I need to add salt for my freshwater puffers?
No. South American Puffers and Tetraodon schoutedeni are true freshwater fish and do not need salt added to the tank. Use clean, stable freshwater that matches their preferred parameters. Only use salt for short-term treatments if recommended for a specific issue.
Will my puffer eat all my snails?
Yes, that is very likely. Puffers love snails and benefit from eating them. If you like decorative snails, do not mix them with puffers. Instead, grow snails in a separate container and feed them to the puffer as needed.
How often should I feed my puffer?
Feed small portions once or twice daily. Young or newly settled puffers may appreciate two small meals. Adults can do well on one daily meal with a varied menu. Include crunchy items several times per week to manage teeth. Remove leftovers to keep water clean.
What are signs my puffer is not doing well?
Loss of appetite, white stringy feces, clamped fins, constant hiding, rapid breathing, or sudden aggression can signal problems. Check water quality first, then consider parasites or dental issues. Quarantine and treat as needed.
Conclusion: making puffers and communities work
Most puffers are not community fish, but two species can work when you plan carefully. South American Puffers and Tetraodon schoutedeni are true freshwater puffers that can live with suitable tank mates in the right environment. Give them space, stable water, sight breaks, and a varied diet with crunchy foods. Choose fast, short-finned companions and avoid shrimp and snails you want to keep as pets. Quarantine puffers and be ready to adjust your stocking if a personality clash appears.
If you set up the tank around the puffer’s needs, you can enjoy the best of both worlds: the charm and intelligence of a puffer fish in a lively, tropical freshwater community. Start with the species in this guide, keep your maintenance consistent, and watch your fish closely. With patience and good planning, a peaceful puffer community is not only possible—it is a joy to watch every day.