We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Mollies and platies are classic livebearers that beginners love. They are colorful, active, and easy to breed. They are also often misunderstood, especially when it comes to water parameters. Many health problems that people blame on disease are actually caused by soft water, unstable pH, or overstocking. This guide explains how to set up the right water for each species, how to breed them reliably, and how to raise strong fry without constant losses.
Why Mollies and Platies Are Worth Your Time
Both species adapt well to home aquariums, display constant activity, and reward consistent care with regular births. They are peaceful community fish when kept in balanced sex ratios, and they eat a wide range of foods. The catch is that mollies have higher mineral demands than platies. Understanding that difference is the key to long-term success.
Quick Species Profile
Mollies at a Glance
Mollies grow larger than platies and include shortfin and sailfin types. Adults reach 3 to 6 inches depending on the variety. They thrive in hard, alkaline water and can even live in mildly brackish conditions. When kept in soft, acidic water, mollies often shimmy, lose condition, and develop disease.
Platies at a Glance
Platies are compact, usually 2 to 3 inches, and come in many colors. They prefer moderate to hard water but are more forgiving than mollies. They breed readily in planted community tanks and are a great introduction to livebearers for new hobbyists.
Tank Setup That Sets You Up for Success
Tank Size and Stocking
For mollies, plan for at least 30 gallons for a small group. Sailfin mollies need the space. For platies, 20 gallons is a sensible minimum for a group. Both species prefer groups of six or more to spread attention and reduce stress. Keep one male for every two or three females to control chasing.
Avoid mixing large numbers of both species in small tanks. Mollies grow bigger, produce more waste, and demand stronger filtration. A split tank plan works well. Keep mollies as the centerpiece in a harder water tank. Keep platies with other community fish in a separate tank if your water is softer.
Filtration and Flow
Use a filter that turns the tank volume over 5 to 8 times per hour. Hang-on-back filters or canisters with a pre-filter sponge on the intake protect fry. For breeding tanks, add a sponge filter to provide gentle, fry-safe filtration and extra biofilm. Ensure good surface agitation to keep oxygen high.
Substrate and Plants
Both fish appreciate planted tanks with open swimming space. Use hardy plants that tolerate alkaline water such as Java fern, Anubias, hornwort, guppy grass, Vallisneria, and floating plants. Plants give pregnant females cover and provide microfoods for fry. Dark sand or fine gravel makes it easy to spot uneaten food and vacuum waste. Leave open areas for active swimming.
Water Parameters That Actually Work
Temperature
Mollies prefer 75 to 82 F, with 78 to 80 F as a sweet spot for activity and breeding. Platies prefer 72 to 79 F, with 74 to 76 F comfortable for mixed community tanks. Use a reliable heater and a thermometer. Avoid big daily swings.
pH, GH, and KH Explained
pH measures acidity or alkalinity. GH measures calcium and magnesium. KH measures carbonate buffering and stabilizes pH. Mollies need strong GH and KH to stay healthy. Platies do best with moderate to strong GH and moderate KH.
For mollies aim for pH 7.5 to 8.4, GH 10 to 25 dGH, KH 8 to 12 dKH. For platies aim for pH 7.0 to 8.2, GH 8 to 20 dGH, KH 4 to 12 dKH. If your tap water is soft, you must add minerals. If your tap is already hard, you are halfway there.
Salt and Minerals for Mollies and Platies
Mollies benefit from mineral-rich water. Salt can help temporarily, but minerals solve the root cause. Prefer remineralization over salt as a long-term plan. Use a GH and KH booster or a commercial remineralizer for livebearers. Crushed coral or aragonite in the filter can also raise KH and stabilize pH.
Salt use is optional. A low dose can help mollies during stress or mild disease. A typical tonic level is about one tablespoon per five gallons, but always consider tank mates and plants. Many plants and some fish dislike salt. Platies do not require salt. If you keep mollies and platies together, keep salt low or skip it and focus on GH and KH instead.
TDS and Testing Routine
TDS stands for total dissolved solids and reflects overall minerals and waste. Use a TDS meter to track stability. Test ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, pH, GH, and KH weekly at first. For mollies, aim for clearly mineralized water and consistent readings. For platies, moderate mineralization works well. Keep nitrate under 20 to 40 ppm. Matching your change water to the tank’s GH and KH prevents shocks.
Cycling and Maintenance That Prevents Disease
Cycle the Tank Before Fish
Do a fishless cycle using bottled bacteria and an ammonia source. Wait until ammonia reads zero, nitrite reads zero, and nitrate rises. Rushing this step is a common cause of shimmying, fin rot, and random deaths.
Water Change Plan
Change 30 to 50 percent weekly for community tanks. For breeding tanks with heavy feeding, consider two smaller changes per week. Vacuum waste, rinse filter media in tank water, and avoid washing away beneficial bacteria. Always dechlorinate new water and match temperature.
How to Handle Soft Tap Water
If your water is soft, add a measured dose of GH and KH buffer to new water before adding it to the tank. Keep notes so you can repeat the same recipe every time. Stability is the goal. This one habit prevents most molly troubles.
Feeding for Health and Breeding Readiness
What to Feed
Mollies and platies are omnivores with a strong need for plant matter. Use a high-quality flake or pellet with spirulina. Add blanched zucchini, spinach, or peas on rotation. Supplement with frozen or live foods such as baby brine shrimp and daphnia. Feed algae in the tank and let them graze on biofilm.
How Much and How Often
Feed small portions two to three times per day for adults. For breeding preparation, increase variety rather than quantity. Remove uneaten vegetables after a few hours. Overfeeding increases waste and disease risk. Aim for consistent body shape with no pinched bellies or massive bulges outside of pregnancy.
Sexing, Ratios, and Community Compatibility
How to Sex Them
Males have a pointed anal fin called a gonopodium. Females have a triangular anal fin and a rounder belly. Males are slimmer and often show more intense colors. Separate sexes if you want to delay breeding.
Ratios That Keep the Peace
Keep one male with two or three females. More females spread out male attention. Too many males equals constant chasing and stress. If males are relentless, add plants and line of sight breaks, or move extra males to another tank.
Good Tank Mates
Choose peaceful fish that like similar water. For mollies, think of swordtails, certain rainbowfish, and hardy livebearers. For platies, community options include peaceful tetras that tolerate moderate hardness, corydoras that handle midrange parameters, and small barbs that are not nippy. Avoid fin nippers and large predatory fish. Check the mineral needs of any bottom dwellers; extreme hard water may not suit soft water species.
Breeding That You Can Plan and Control
Signs of Pregnancy
Livebearer females develop a fuller belly and a darkening area near the vent called the gravid spot. Behavior may include hiding or staying near dense plants toward the end of pregnancy. Gestation is typically 24 to 35 days depending on temperature and species. Mollies often carry larger broods than platies.
Birthing Setups
Use a well-planted tank with fine-leaved plants like guppy grass and Java moss. Floating plants give extra cover. A breeder box can work short term, but do not confine the female for long periods because confinement adds stress. Many keepers have success letting females drop in the main tank and letting only a portion of fry survive, then collecting some fry to raise separately.
Fry Survival and First Foods
Adults can eat fry. Plants reduce losses. If you want high survival, move the female to a separate nursery tank just before birth and return her within 24 hours after birth. Keep the nursery filtered by a sponge filter and maintain stable temperature.
Feed fry very small meals three to five times daily at first. Use powdered fry food, crushed high-quality flakes, live microworms, or freshly hatched baby brine shrimp. For the first week, prioritize small particle size. As they grow, increase food size and reduce frequency. Perform small daily water changes in the nursery to keep water clean without shocking fry.
Preventing Overpopulation
Separate sexes to stop breeding. Keep only females or only males if you do not want fry. Remember that females can store sperm and produce several broods after being separated from males. Remove excess fry promptly, rehome through local stores or hobby groups, and avoid overcrowding. If space is limited, let the main tank’s plants and community manage survival rates naturally rather than trying to save every fry.
Water Tweaks That Improve Breeding Results
Triggers You Can Control
Offer stable warmth, frequent small water changes, and a nutritious varied diet. Slightly raising temperature within the safe range often speeds gestation and increases activity. For mollies, ensure strong GH and KH, and consider a very mild salt level if you are not using sensitive plants or tank mates. For platies, moderate hardness is enough, and clean water is the main driver.
Fry Water and Filtration
Keep fry in the same parameters as the parents to avoid acclimation stress. Use gentle filtration with a sponge filter. Maintain oxygenation and avoid strong currents. Perform small but frequent water changes to dilute waste. Match temperature and minerals carefully to prevent shock.
Common Problems and Fast Fixes
Shimmying in Mollies
Shimmying looks like trembling in place. It is usually a mineral issue or stress from ammonia and nitrite. Check ammonia and nitrite first; both must be zero. Then test GH and KH. Raise GH and KH to the target range for mollies. Consider a small salt dose short term while you correct minerals. Improve aeration and avoid sudden parameter changes.
Ich, Fin Rot, and Columnaris
Ich appears as white spots and flashing. Treat promptly with a proven ich medication, stable temperature, and high oxygen. Fin rot presents as frayed fins and usually indicates poor water quality. Fix maintenance first and treat secondary infection if needed. Columnaris presents as white patches or cottony growth near the mouth or dorsal area and progresses fast in warm, dirty water. Improve water quality and treat with an appropriate antibacterial. Always remove chemical filtration like carbon during treatment if the product instructions require it.
Pregnancy Complications
Overstressed females may abort or have difficult births. Provide cover, reduce harassment using proper male to female ratios, and maintain stable parameters. Do not isolate females too early or too long. Keep transport and netting to a minimum near the due date.
Deformities and Inbreeding
Repeated inbreeding can produce weak fry and deformities. Source fish from different breeders to refresh genetics. Avoid balloon morphs if you want robust, natural swimming. Cull humanely only when necessary and focus on prevention through careful selection.
Algae, Cloudy Water, and Odors
Algae blooms often point to high light or excess nutrients. Shorten the light period and feed less. Cloudy water after a new setup is usually bacterial bloom and clears with time and stable maintenance. Persistent odor signals waste buildup; increase water change volume and clean the filter intake and substrate thoroughly.
Keeping Mollies and Platies Together
You can keep them together if your water meets the needs of the pickier species, which is the molly. That means hard, alkaline water. Platies usually adapt well. Avoid brackish levels of salt if you keep sensitive plants and mixed community fish. If your tap water is very soft and you do not want to add minerals, keep platies only and skip mollies.
Acclimation That Prevents Shock
When bringing fish home, match temperature and minerals gradually. If the store water is much softer or harder than your tank, use a slow drip acclimation process. Discard transport water and net the fish into the tank. Test parameters after stocking and watch for clamped fins, gasping, or frantic swimming. Catch problems early.
A Simple Weekly Routine
Testing and Observation
Once a week, test pH, GH, KH, ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate. Daily, do a quick check for behavior changes, damaged fins, or unusual spots. Early action prevents losses.
Water Changes
Change 30 to 50 percent weekly. Pre-mix minerals if needed. Match temperature and aerate new water if your tap is gassy. Clean the filter intake sponge and gently swish sponge media in tank water. Do not overclean biomedia. Consistency beats intensity.
Feeding and Plant Care
Feed varied foods in modest amounts. Rotate vegetable items and protein-rich treats. Trim fast-growing plants and remove decaying leaves. Healthy plants buffer water quality and help fry survive.
Breeding Timeline Example
From Setup to Fry
Week one to four, cycle the tank and plant heavily. Week five, add a small group with correct ratios. Week six to eight, establish feeding routine and confirm stable GH and KH. Females will likely be pregnant already. Week eight to twelve, expect first drops of fry. At birth, either let the main tank manage survival or move fry to a nursery tank with a sponge filter. Feed fry small meals often and change water gently but frequently. Within two to three months, juveniles begin to show sex differences.
Troubleshooting Checklist
When Fish Struggle, Check These First
Are ammonia and nitrite zero. Is nitrate under 40 ppm. Is pH stable day to day. Are GH and KH in range for the species. Is the temperature consistent and within the preferred range. Is there enough oxygen. Is the tank overcrowded. Are you feeding too much. Fix the root causes before reaching for medication.
Ethical and Practical Notes
Responsible Breeding
Have a plan for fry before they arrive. Contact local stores or fellow hobbyists to rehome extras. Maintain separate lines if you want to avoid accidental crosses between similar species or strains. Keep records of dates, parameters, and outcomes. Good records turn guesswork into progress.
Beginner-Friendly Parameter Targets
For Mollies
Temperature 78 to 80 F. pH 7.5 to 8.2. GH 12 to 20 dGH. KH 8 to 12 dKH. Optional mild salt if plants and tank mates tolerate it. High oxygen and clean, mineral-rich water are non-negotiable.
For Platies
Temperature 74 to 76 F. pH 7.0 to 8.0. GH 8 to 16 dGH. KH 4 to 8 dKH. No salt needed. Clean water and a balanced diet make breeding almost automatic.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do mollies need brackish water
No, but they benefit from hard, alkaline water with strong mineral content. Mild salt can help short term. True brackish is optional and not ideal for planted community tanks.
Can I keep them in the same tank
Yes if you maintain hard, alkaline water. Platies tolerate it. If your tap water is soft and you do not want to remineralize, stick to platies only.
How often will they breed
Females can give birth every four to six weeks after mating, and stored sperm can produce multiple broods. Control population by separating sexes and limiting hiding spaces if you do not plan to raise fry.
Why are my mollies trembling
Likely mineral deficiency or poor water quality. Test GH, KH, ammonia, and nitrite. Remineralize and correct the cycle.
What is the easiest first food for fry
Crushed high-quality flakes and powdered fry food work. For best growth and survival, add baby brine shrimp and microworms. Feed tiny amounts several times daily and keep water pristine.
Conclusion
Healthy mollies and platies are not a mystery. Give mollies firm mineral support with high GH and KH, keep platies in clean, moderately hard water, and maintain stable temperature and pH. Feed a plant-forward varied diet and control stocking. Set up a gentle, planted environment with a fry-safe filter if you plan to breed. When problems appear, test water first and fix the fundamentals before medicating.
Follow these steps and you will see steady growth, vivid colors, natural breeding behavior, and strong fry. Start with stable water, match the needs of each species, and let consistent routines do the heavy lifting.