We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
If you are setting up a new aquarium, you will quickly face a classic choice: should you use real plants or plastic plants? Both can make your tank look beautiful. Both can give your fish places to hide and explore. But they are very different in how they affect water quality, maintenance, and long‑term costs. This guide explains the real pros and cons of live and artificial plants in simple terms, so you can make the best choice for your fish, your schedule, and your budget.
There is no single right answer for everyone. The best choice is the one that fits your goals and your lifestyle. Read on to learn what each option offers, where it falls short, and how to decide what will work in your tank today—and still make you happy six months from now.
The Big Question: Real or Plastic Plants?
Live plants are living filters that interact with your water. They grow, use nutrients, and change over time. Plastic (and silk) plants are decorations that stay the same and require less day‑to‑day care. Most beginners worry that live plants are too hard. In reality, many easy live plants are very forgiving. The choice depends on how much you want to learn, how much time you have, and what your fish need.
Real Plants: Pros
Natural Filtration and Water Quality
Live plants act like tiny water cleaners. They use ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate—the waste products from fish and leftover food—as nutrients. This helps keep nitrate from building up too quickly. It does not replace water changes, but it helps stabilize your water and creates a healthier environment, especially in community tanks.
Oxygen and CO2 Balance
During the day, plants photosynthesize. They use carbon dioxide and release oxygen into the water. This can increase oxygen levels and make fish more comfortable. At night, plants breathe like animals and use oxygen, but in most tanks with a filter and surface movement, this is not a problem. The net effect is often positive for fish and beneficial bacteria.
Natural Behavior and Stress Reduction
Live plants look and feel natural. Fish use real leaves to hide, graze, and explore. Shy species gain confidence, which reduces stress and strengthens the immune system. Shrimp and fry (baby fish) also benefit, because real plants provide micro‑food and dense cover to protect them from larger tank mates.
Algae Control (When Conditions Are Right)
Plants compete with algae for nutrients and light. If you give your plants what they need—enough light and basic nutrients—they grow and use nutrients that would otherwise feed algae. This does not mean you will never see algae, but live plants make algae easier to manage and less likely to take over.
A Living, Changing Look
A planted tank grows and evolves. You can trim stems, replant cuttings, and reshape your aquascape over time. Many hobbyists enjoy this creative side. The movement of real leaves in the current also adds soft, natural motion that fake plants cannot fully copy.
Real Plants: Cons
Maintenance and Learning Curve
Live plants need simple care. You may trim overgrown stems, remove dying leaves, and occasionally vacuum around roots. The learning curve includes understanding light levels, fertilizer, and how to plant correctly. For many people this is fun, but if you want a zero‑maintenance decoration, real plants may feel like work.
Lighting and Nutrients
Plants need enough light to grow. The standard light that comes with some tank kits is often too weak. Many easy plants still do fine with a decent LED running 6 to 8 hours a day. Some plants need root tabs, liquid fertilizer, or both. The good news: you can pick species that match your light and budget.
Risk of Pests and Disease
Live plants can carry snails, algae, or pathogens when not handled well. Rinsing, quarantining, or using a gentle dip before planting greatly reduces risk. Buying from trusted sources and choosing tissue‑culture plants (grown in sterile cups) also helps avoid hitchhikers.
Upfront Cost and Availability
Easy live plants are not expensive, but the initial setup—better light, substrate for roots, and fertilizer—can cost more than plastic plants. If your local store has limited plant choices, you may need to order online. Once established, though, plants can be propagated, which saves money long term.
Compatibility with Fish and Substrate
Some fish, like large cichlids or goldfish, may dig or nibble plants. You must pick tougher species or plant them in ways that protect the roots. Substrate matters too: rooted plants do better in sand or fine gravel than in large, sharp gravel that damages roots.
Plastic (and Silk) Plants: Pros
Low Maintenance and Reliability
Fake plants do not need light, fertilizers, or trimming. They never melt or turn yellow. If your main goal is a clean, controlled look with minimum effort, plastic or silk plants make things very simple. You can set the tank up fast and it will look the same day after day.
Safe for Quarantine and Medication
When treating fish with medication, some drugs can harm live plants. Plastic and silk plants are unaffected. They are also useful in temporary hospital or quarantine tanks because you can remove and disinfect them easily after treatment.
Design Freedom
Plastic plants come in many shapes and colors. You can build a theme with bold accents or choose a realistic look. Tall fake plants help hide filters or heaters. You can place them wherever you like without worrying about lighting zones or root depth.
Budget and Availability
In many areas, fake plants are cheaper up front and easier to find locally. For a beginner on a strict budget who wants instant coverage, several plastic plants can fill space without buying new lights or substrate. They also last a long time if you clean them well.
Plastic Plants: Cons
No Real Filtration or Oxygenation
Plastic plants are decorations only. They do not remove nitrate or release oxygen the way live plants can. You must rely fully on your filter, water changes, and good feeding habits to control waste. This is fine, but it removes a useful support system that live plants provide.
Algae Magnet and Cleaning Needs
Algae will grow on plastic and silk plants. Since they do not grow, they cannot outcompete algae. Over time, fake leaves can look dull or stained if you do not clean them regularly. In tanks with strong light or heavy feeding, algae on plastic plants can become a frequent chore.
Safety Concerns with Hard Plastic
Some hard plastic plants have sharp edges that can tear fins, especially for fish like bettas and fancy guppies. Silk plants are softer and safer, with more flexible leaves. If you choose plastic, check the texture with your fingers. If it scratches your skin, it might scratch your fish.
Less Natural Behavior
While fake plants still offer shelter, they do not provide biofilm, grazing surfaces, or real leaf movement. Shy fish may still hide, but the tank will not develop the same tiny food sources and micro‑habitats that live plants create, which matters for shrimp and fry.
Silk vs Hard Plastic: What’s the Difference?
Silk plants have soft fabric leaves on plastic stems. They look more natural in the water and are gentle on fins. Hard plastic plants are more rigid and can hold shape better, but may have sharp points. If you keep long‑finned fish or delicate species, silk is the safer choice. If you choose hard plastic, run your fingers along the leaves and trim any rough spots. Rinse both types before use to remove dust or manufacturing residue.
Choosing Based on Your Setup
If You Want Low Effort and Predictable Results
Pick mostly fake plants. Use silk plants for soft movement and safety. Combine different heights to fill space and hide equipment. Keep lighting moderate to reduce algae. Plan routine cleaning: during water changes, lift out fake plants, scrub algae with a soft brush, and rinse in removed tank water before putting them back.
If You Keep Goldfish or Messy/Digging Cichlids
These fish often uproot or chew plants. Use fake plants with weighted bases or rocky decor to anchor them, or try tough live plants like Anubias and Java fern attached to wood or rocks. Avoid delicate stems they can shred. Keep décor simple and sturdy. For goldfish, cooler water also limits plant options, so choose hardier species or stick with realistic silk plants.
If You Keep Shrimp, Small Community Fish, or Bettas
Live plants shine here. Shrimp and fry graze on biofilm that grows on leaves. Bettas enjoy resting on broad leaves and appreciate dense cover. Try easy live plants like Java fern, Anubias, and floating plants. If you mix in fake plants, choose silk to protect fins and place them away from strong filter flow.
If You Want a Lush, High‑Tech Aquascape
Go with real plants and plan your equipment. You will want a good LED, regular fertilizing, and maybe CO2 for demanding species. Start with easy to medium plants while you learn. Trim weekly, keep your schedule steady, and enjoy the creative process. The result can be stunning and very rewarding.
Maintenance: Simple Routines That Work
Basic Care for Live Plants
Start with a steady light schedule of 6 to 8 hours a day. Use a timer so it is consistent. Add a complete liquid fertilizer once or twice a week for leaf‑feeding plants. For rooted plants like Amazon swords and Cryptocoryne, push root tabs near the roots every couple of months. Trim dying leaves before they rot, and replant healthy stem cuttings to make the scape fuller.
Cleaning Plastic and Silk Plants
During water changes, remove one or two plants at a time. Gently scrub algae with a soft toothbrush. Rinse in a bucket of tank water, not under hot tap water, to avoid shocking your fish with residues. If algae stains build up, soak plants briefly in a mild bleach solution (1 part bleach to 20 parts water), then rinse very well and dechlorinate before returning them to the tank.
Realistic Expectations About Algae
Every aquarium grows some algae. With live plants, the goal is balance: enough light and nutrients for the plants to thrive, but not so much that algae blooms. With plastic plants, the goal is control: keep lighting moderate, do not overfeed, and clean leaves during regular maintenance. Algae is a sign of life, not failure. Over time, you will learn what your tank likes.
Easy Live Plants to Consider
Low‑Light, Beginner‑Friendly Choices
Java fern and Anubias attach to wood or rock and do not need rich substrate. Java moss and Christmas moss create soft carpets and shrimp hideouts. Cryptocoryne and Amazon swords are rooted plants that grow well with root tabs. Floating plants like Salvinia and frogbit shade the tank, help reduce algae, and give nervous fish cover near the surface.
Plants for Goldfish and Tough Keepers
Try Anubias and Java fern glued to rocks or driftwood so they cannot be dug up. Hornwort and elodea can be left floating if planted stems get uprooted. Avoid soft, tasty plants like cabomba that fish quickly shred. Keep an eye on nibbled leaves and replace or trim as needed.
Mixing Real and Fake Plants: A Smart Middle Ground
You do not have to choose only one. Many aquarists mix a few easy live plants with well‑placed silk plants. Use live plants where they make the most difference—like fast‑growing stems in the back to soak up nutrients—and silk plants in shaded corners or high‑traffic zones where live plants struggle. This hybrid approach gives you some natural benefits with less risk and maintenance.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Too Much Light, Not Enough Nutrients
Blasting bright light without feeding your plants leads to algae explosions. If you see algae, reduce the photoperiod to 6 hours, add basic fertilizer, and increase plant mass with a few fast‑growing stems. Consistency beats intensity. Small changes held steady for a few weeks work better than constant big adjustments.
Overcleaning or Harsh Chemicals
Scrubbing everything spotless every week removes beneficial bacteria. Clean gently, rinse filter media in tank water, and avoid soap. If you use a bleach dip on fake plants, rinse several times and use dechlorinator. For live plants, many dips are too harsh. Quarantine new plants instead, or use mild dips like diluted potassium permanganate with care.
How to Decide: A Quick Self‑Check
What is your maintenance style?
If you enjoy gardening and small weekly tasks, live plants are a great fit. If you want a set‑and‑forget display, plastic or silk may suit you better. You can always start simple and add live plants later as you gain confidence.
What do your fish need?
Long‑finned or delicate fish prefer silk or soft live plants. Shrimp and fry do best with live plants. Big diggers and chewers may push you toward silk and hardscape, or very tough live species glued to wood and rocks. Match your plants to your fish, not the other way around.
What is your budget?
Plastic plants are cheaper at first. Live plants can cost more upfront if you need a better light and fertilizer, but they often save money over time as they grow and fill the tank. Decide if you want to invest once or spread costs across several months.
Sample Setups That Work
Beginner Community Tank
20‑gallon tank, moderate LED, Java fern and Anubias on wood, a few silk plants to fill gaps, weekly 30 percent water changes, and a 7‑hour light schedule. Peaceful fish like tetras, rasboras, and a small group of corydoras will thrive.
Low‑Effort Betta Tank
5 to 10 gallons, gentle filter, silk plants with broad leaves plus a clump of Java moss, floating plant cover, 6‑hour light, and weekly partial water changes. The betta gets safe resting spots and calm spaces without heavy plant care.
Goldfish Tank
40 gallons or larger, smooth silk plants with heavy bases, Anubias and Java fern tied to rocks, strong filtration, and regular gravel vacuuming. Keep lighting moderate to reduce algae, and avoid thin plastic leaves that can snag fins.
Troubleshooting Quick Wins
Live Plants Turning Yellow or Melting
Check the light schedule, reduce to 6 to 7 hours if algae is visible, and start a simple fertilizer routine. For rooted plants, add root tabs near the base. Many plants “melt” after moving but recover with stable conditions and patience.
Fake Plants Covered in Algae
Shorten the light period, feed less, and clean a few plants at every water change. Increase surface agitation for better oxygenation, and consider adding a few fast‑growing live stems to compete with algae, even if most of your scape is artificial.
Conclusion
Real and plastic aquarium plants both have a place in the hobby. Live plants support water quality, natural behavior, and a living, evolving aquascape. Plastic and silk plants offer predictability, low maintenance, and easy design. Your best choice depends on your fish, your schedule, and your goals. If you are unsure, start small: try a few hardy live plants alongside quality silk plants and see how your tank responds. Over time, you can shift toward more live growth or keep a balanced mix. The most important thing is to build a tank you enjoy caring for—because a tank you love is a tank that thrives.