We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
If you have ever seen a small, cute fish at the store and thought “This will fit my tank forever,” this guide is for you. Many new aquarists are surprised when a tiny juvenile grows into a huge, powerful fish that no home aquarium can handle. In the hobby, we call these species “tankbusters.” Understanding what a tankbuster is will save you money, protect your fish, and keep you from heartbreak later. This beginner-friendly guide explains the term, lists common tankbusters to avoid, offers safer alternatives, and shows what to do if you already own one.
What Does “Tankbuster” Mean?
A tankbuster is a fish that grows so large, or needs so much space and filtration, that most home aquariums cannot house it properly for life. These fish are often sold as tiny juveniles that look harmless. Many can reach 30–150 cm (12–60 inches) as adults, and some never stop growing.
The word “tankbuster” does not mean the fish is bad. It simply means the species becomes too big, too active, or too messy for typical tanks like 75–200 liters (20–55 gallons). Some tankbusters also have strong jaws, jump hard enough to break lids, or create so much waste that water quality collapses without industrial-level filtration.
In short: a tankbuster needs a pond or a very large, specialized setup. Without that, the fish will suffer, become unhealthy, or start destroying your aquascape and equipment.
Why Tankbusters Are a Problem in Home Aquariums
Size and Growth Speed
Many tankbusters grow from 5 cm to 30–60 cm (2 inches to 12–24 inches) within a year or two under good care. They can double in length and multiply in mass fast. A tank that looked fine last month is suddenly too small.
Huge Waste and Filtration Needs
Big fish eat a lot and produce a lot of waste. Ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate rise quickly. You will need powerful filtration, large water changes, and often a sump to keep water safe. This is time-consuming and expensive.
Space to Swim, Turn, and Breathe
Long or wide tanks matter more than tall tanks for big fish. Some species need several times their body length in swimming space. If a fish cannot turn comfortably or rush forward when startled, it will injure itself and become stressed.
Aggression and Stress
As many tankbusters grow, they become territorial or predatory. They may swallow tank mates, shred fins, or panic and crash into glass. Schooling species get anxious when kept alone, but a proper group may require a pond-sized tank.
Jumping and Equipment Damage
Powerful fish jump, ram lids, and push heaters or filters. Broken lids and cracked lights are common. Some fish can hurt themselves badly during a panicked rush in a small tank.
Long Lifespans and Big Commitments
Tankbusters may live 10–20 years or more. They outlast trends, apartments, and sometimes your budget. Many owners struggle to rehome large fish, and public aquariums rarely accept them.
Ethics, Law, and Environment
Releasing fish into the wild is illegal in many places and can harm local ecosystems. Some tankbusters become invasive species. Keeping a fish you cannot properly house is stressful for you and unfair to the animal.
Common Tankbuster Species to Watch Out For
Redtail Catfish (Phractocephalus hemioliopterus)
Juveniles are adorable, but adults reach 120–150 cm (4–5 feet). They swallow anything that fits in their mouth and need a pond or thousands of liters of water. A home aquarium is almost never suitable long-term.
Iridescent Shark / Pangasius (Pangasianodon hypophthalmus)
These are not sharks, but river catfish that grow 90–120 cm (3–4 feet). They are nervous, fast swimmers that panic easily and need huge, long tanks or ponds to avoid injury. They also prefer groups, which increases space needs.
Common Pleco (Hypostomus/Pterygoplichthys spp.)
Frequently sold as “algae eaters,” common plecos reach 45–60 cm (18–24 inches) and produce tons of waste. They can outgrow 200 liters (55 gallons) quickly. Many are later abandoned. Choose smaller pleco species instead.
Pacu (Colossoma/Piaractus spp.)
Pacu look like big piranhas but are mainly plant-eaters. They reach 60–75 cm (24–30 inches), have strong jaws, and need massive tanks with open swimming space. A school requires a very large aquarium or pond.
Silver Arowana (Osteoglossum bicirrhosum)
Graceful and stunning, silver arowanas grow to 90 cm (36 inches) or more. They are powerful jumpers and need long, wide tanks with tight covers. Even a 180–240 gallon tank is often a temporary solution, not a lifelong home.
Giant Gourami (Osphronemus goramy)
Despite the name “gourami,” this is not a community fish. Adults reach 60–70 cm (24–28 inches), are very strong, and may rearrange your tank. They need large tanks and heavy filtration.
Clown Knifefish (Chitala ornata)
Beautiful pattern, but adults commonly reach 60–90 cm (24–35 inches). They are nocturnal, can be skittish, and need big footprints and calm tank mates. Often outgrow home aquariums within a couple of years.
Paroon Shark (Pangasius sanitwongsei)
One of the largest freshwater fish offered in the trade, reaching several feet. It should never be sold for home aquariums. Requires public aquarium scale care.
Tiger Shovelnose Catfish (Pseudoplatystoma spp.)
Fast-growing predators that can reach 90–120 cm (3–4 feet). They will eat tank mates and need massive, secure tanks with excellent filtration.
Oscar (Astronotus ocellatus) – A “Near Tankbuster”
Oscars reach 30–35 cm (12–14 inches). With the right setup, a single oscar can live well in a 280-liter (75-gallon) tank, but pairs need at least 475 liters (125 gallons). They are messy, intelligent, and strong. Many people buy them without understanding the true space and filtration needed.
Why Do Stores Still Sell Them?
Tankbusters are popular because juveniles look cute and interesting. They are also common in the supply chain. Some sellers assume customers will upgrade or already own large tanks. Labels may be vague, showing only juvenile size or using common names that hide adult size. There are also myths that fish “grow to the size of the tank,” which is not true and leads to stunted, unhealthy fish.
As the buyer, it helps to research before you purchase. You are the last line of defense for your future fish.
How to Avoid Accidentally Buying a Tankbuster
Search the Scientific Name
Ask for the fish’s scientific name and look it up on your phone. Common names like “shark,” “pleco,” or “catfish” can refer to many species, some tiny and some huge. Scientific names reduce confusion.
Check Adult Size, Not Juvenile Size
Only adult size matters. If a fish can reach 60 cm (24 inches), your 110-liter (29-gallon) tank will not work. Consider swimming style too, not just length.
Ask About Behavior and Diet
Predators, constant swimmers, and heavy feeders all need more space. Schooling fish need groups. No single piece of information is enough—look at the whole picture.
Be Wary of “Common” Labels
“Common pleco” is a red flag. “Iridescent shark” is a red flag. If the label is vague, do not buy until you confirm the exact species and adult size.
Use Your Phone in the Store
A 60-second search can save you years of trouble. Look for multiple sources, not just one forum post. If in doubt, walk away and research more.
Safer Look-Alike Alternatives for Small and Mid-Size Tanks
Instead of a Common Pleco
Choose a Bristlenose Pleco (Ancistrus spp.), usually 10–15 cm (4–6 inches). They are hardy, good algae grazers, and fit well in 75–150 liters (20–40 gallons) depending on stocking. Clown Pleco (Panaqolus maccus) stays around 8–10 cm (3–4 inches) but prefers wood to rasp on. Rubberlip Pleco (Chaetostoma spp.) stays small but likes cooler, high-oxygen water.
Instead of an Iridescent Shark
If you like the sleek “shark” look, consider a Rainbow Shark (Epalzeorhynchos frenatum) at about 12–15 cm (5–6 inches). It is semi-aggressive and needs a mature 115–150 liter tank (30–40 gallons) with hiding spots. For algae control, Siamese Algae Eater (Crossocheilus spp.) grows to about 15 cm (6 inches) and does better in groups in 200+ liters (55+ gallons). Always research compatibility and territory needs.
Instead of a Silver Arowana
For a surface predator vibe in a reasonable tank, try an African Butterfly Fish (Pantodon buchholzi). It grows to around 10–13 cm (4–5 inches), prefers calm water, and needs a tight lid. A 110–150 liter (29–40 gallon) long tank can work. For active top-dwellers in groups, consider hatchetfish species in a secure, covered aquarium.
Instead of a Pacu
Silver Dollars (Metynnis/Myleus/Myleopsis spp.) reach about 15 cm (6 inches) and like to be in groups. A 200–300 liter (55–75 gallon) tank with strong filtration and room to swim is a good starting point. They offer the same shimmering, disc-like look without the pond-level size.
Instead of Giant Predatory Catfish
Smaller catfish options include Pictus Catfish (Pimelodus pictus), which reach around 12–15 cm (5–6 inches) and are very active, or Synodontis species like S. lucipinnis/petricola around 10–12 cm (4–5 inches). These still need proper space and groups, but they do not become monsters.
If You Already Own a Tankbuster: A Realistic Care Plan
Identify the Species and Adult Size
Get the exact scientific name. Confirm adult size, behavior, temperature needs, and diet. This tells you how quickly you must act.
Plan an Upgrade or Rehome Timeline
Set a clear deadline. If your fish will outgrow your tank in six months, decide now whether you will upgrade or rehome. Do not wait until the fish is already too big.
Improve Care Immediately
Increase water changes to keep ammonia and nitrite at zero and nitrate very low. Add stronger filtration or a sump. Ensure strong aeration and a tight-fitting lid. Provide a simple layout with open swimming space so the fish can turn and move without injury.
Feed a Balanced Diet, Not Just Growth Food
A varied diet supports health. Avoid overfeeding high-protein pellets that drive rapid growth if your space is limited. Feed enough for condition, then remove leftovers to keep water clean.
Reduce Stress and Risk
Limit tank mates that may be eaten or may harass the big fish. Dim the lights if the fish is skittish. Cover dark sides of the tank to reduce reflections and panic. Make sure heaters are protected and cables are secure.
Rehoming Options
Contact local aquarium clubs, large-tank hobbyists, and reputable fish stores that accept returns or trade-ins. Use regional fish groups and forums. Be honest about size, species, and behavior. Never release fish into local waters. Public aquariums rarely accept common tankbusters because they receive many requests and have limited space.
Transport Tips
Fast the fish for 24 hours before moving to reduce waste. Use a strong container with a secure lid. For large fish, consider heavy-duty coolers and a battery air pump. Keep the fish warm and stable during transport.
Setting Up for a True Giant (Advanced Keepers Only)
If you are committed to keeping a tankbuster for life, plan for very large systems. Think in terms of a pond or a custom tank with a large footprint, not just volume. A 300–1000+ gallon system with strong flow, oxygenation, and a large sump is common for big arowanas, catfish, or knifefish.
Use multiple heaters for redundancy and a controller to avoid overheating. Secure lids with weights or locks. Protect heaters and plumbing from strong fish. Plan for power backups if possible, because big fish die quickly in low oxygen.
Target stable water quality with heavy biofiltration and mechanical filtration. Expect large, frequent water changes, often 50–80% weekly, with full dechlorination and temperature matching. Budget for food, electricity, and replacement parts. A big-fish setup is closer to running a small life support system than a normal aquarium.
Growth and “Stunting” Myths
Fish do not safely “grow to the size of the tank.” In small tanks, growth may slow or stop, but organs and spine can deform, and stress hormones rise. Stunted fish are not healthy and usually live shorter lives. Proper space, clean water, and correct diet are essential for normal development.
Another myth is that keeping a fish slightly hungry will keep it small. This is harmful. Underfeeding weakens immunity and does not solve space needs. Plan for the adult size or choose a different species.
Basic Care Checklist Before You Buy Any Fish
Confirm Adult Size and Space Needs
Know the maximum size and the recommended tank size and shape. Long tanks are better for active swimmers. Height is less important than length and width for big fish.
Match Water Parameters
Check temperature, pH, hardness, and flow preferences. A fish that needs warm, soft water will not thrive in a cool, hard-water setup, and vice versa.
Understand Diet and Behavior
Predators may eat smaller tank mates. Schooling fish need groups. Territorial fish may need defined boundaries and hiding places. Plan the community accordingly.
Check Filtration and Maintenance
Make sure your filter handles the bio-load. Know your water change routine before you buy. If the new fish doubles your work, be prepared.
Ask About Lifespan
Some fish live 10–20 years. Only commit if you can support them long-term. If you move often or have limited space, choose small, peaceful species.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a fish only grow to the size of its tank?
No. This is a myth. Small tanks stunt growth and harm health. Fish need proper space to develop normally.
Can I keep a Redtail Catfish in a 180-gallon tank?
No. Redtail catfish eventually need a pond or a system far larger than 180 gallons. Even 300 gallons is not enough long-term.
Are Oscars tankbusters?
Oscars are large and messy but not true tankbusters. A single oscar needs about 75 gallons with strong filtration. Pairs need at least 125 gallons. They are often mis-housed in smaller tanks.
Can big fish live with goldfish?
Usually not. Temperature, diet, and behavior differ greatly. Many big fish will also try to eat goldfish. It is rarely a safe mix.
My big fish keeps crashing into the glass. Why?
The tank may be too small, too bright, or have reflections that scare the fish. Provide more space, reduce reflections, dim the lighting, and keep a tight lid to prevent injuries.
Is a 6-foot tank enough for a Silver Arowana?
It is often a temporary solution for a growing juvenile, not ideal for life. Adults need more space, a wider footprint, and secure covers. Many owners move to indoor ponds or custom builds.
Realistic Examples of Good Choices
For a 75–150 liter tank (20–40 gallons)
Bristlenose pleco, small tetras, corydoras, dwarf gourami, a single rainbow shark with careful planning, or a peaceful community with shrimp and snails. Research each species to confirm compatibility.
For a 200–300 liter tank (55–75 gallons)
Groups of silver dollars, schools of larger tetras or barbs, pictus catfish groups, angelfish communities, or a single oscar with strong filtration in the larger end of this range.
For a 375–475 liter tank (100–125 gallons)
Larger cichlid communities with careful stocking, bigger peaceful catfish, or a pair of oscars with powerful filtration and good aquascape design. Always plan for maintenance and aggression management.
Practical Tips for the Store Visit
Read Labels Carefully
If you see “common pleco,” “iridescent shark,” or just “shark,” pause and research. If no scientific name is shown, ask.
Ignore Sales Pressure
It is okay to say you need to research and come back. A fish is a long-term commitment. A good store will respect that.
Bring a Shortlist
Arrive with two or three species you know are suitable for your tank. Have backup choices. This prevents impulse buys.
Ethical Aquariums Start with Planning
A healthy aquarium is more than a glass box with water. It is a life support system. Fish depend on you for space, clean water, proper food, and safety. When you plan for adult size and natural behavior, your fish live better and you enjoy the hobby more.
Conclusion
Tankbusters are impressive animals, but they are not suitable for most home aquariums. The term describes any species that will outgrow common tanks, demand industrial-level filtration, or pose risks to itself and your setup. Before buying, always check the scientific name, confirm adult size and behavior, and plan for the fish’s full life. If you already own a tankbuster, act quickly to improve care and plan a responsible upgrade or rehome.
There are many beautiful, manageable alternatives that fit small and mid-size tanks and let you build a peaceful, healthy community. With a bit of research and honest planning, you can avoid the tankbuster trap and enjoy a thriving aquarium for years to come.